How extraordinary that a politician so indifferent to being the laughing stock of the world, should take umbrage because a jogging student made a rude sign at his motorcade. It suggests that President Jacob Zuma’s affability is a mask, the rhino hide a paper-thin illusion.
A presidential Goon Squad arrested the irreverent University of Cape Town sociology student Chumani Maxwele at gunpoint. Embarrassingly, he proved to be not a dangerous anarchist concealing homicidal intentions behind his extended middle-finger, but a card-carrying African National Congress activist.
Maxwele, somewhat implausibly, claims that he was not making rude signs but waving away the noisy, fume-belching, blue-light brigade because they were spoiling his jogging pleasure. Even more implausibly, Zuma’s head-thumpers explained that they had to draw weapons on Maxwele, rough him up and bundle him into the backseat with a bag over his head, because he “resisted arrest”.
He was then whisked away — first to Zuma’s official home and then to a police station where he was held for some 24 hours and allegedly verbal abused and interrogated by intelligence operatives, who also searched his home. Zuma’s office refused afterwards to comment on a “security issue”. Given their boss’s propensity for gaffes and bad publicity, one would have hoped for something a little cleverer.
But while it is true that the Z-squad’s reaction was completely disproportionate to what Maxwele supposedly had done, in a strange way he should count himself fortunate. The more usual fate of those allegedly resisting arrest is to be shot dead.
Instead, Maxwele escaped with a charge of crimen injuria, but the jeering jogger will in fact not be prosecuted. Disappointingly for Zuma, South Africa does not yet have laws that make a bad attitude to authority a flogging offence.
President Robert Mugabe would cheer the zeal of Zuma’s protectors, while chuckling at their lack of legislative foresight. The Mugger of the Nation has long since made it a serious offence in Zimbabwe for anyone to demean his exalted status with zap signs, back-of-the-hand sniggers, lewd sucking noises, eye-rolling, nose-picking, earhole excavation or scrotum scratching. Arse-licking by his subjects remains tolerated, even encouraged.
Meanwhile, the shallow soil of South African democracy is demonstrated by the risible statements emanating from the police. The Thug Squad’s actions were entirely justified, according to SS spokesperson, Hauptbefehlsleiter Zweli Mnisi, because Maxwele’s gesture was “synonymous with swearing and disrespect”.
Rude gestures would not be tolerated, ranted Obergruppenführer Mnisi, “especially as such conduct may lead to promoting hate conduct … and it needs to be understood that police have a duty to safeguard all citizens, and anyone who poses danger (sic) or becomes unruly will face the full might of the law”.
Sturmtruppenoberst Mnisi could not actually identify which specific law was contravened when one thumbed one’s nose at an anonymous, tinted-window motorcade, except to say that “morally, you just can’t swear at people”. Well, umm, actually you can, dimwit.
The Constitution protects free speech, including by those who are rude and disrespectful, thank goodness. In any case, as constitutional law expert Pierre de Vos points out, “If showing a middle finger was a criminal offence, half of South Africa would find themselves in prison”.
Zuma is generally astute and much of his charm lies the fact that he is accessible, genial, and puts on none of the pompous airs of his predecessor, former president Thabo Mbeki. The best way to recover from this fiasco would be to invite the now rather disillusioned young comrade for a beer at Tuynhuys, while simultaneously kicking some blue-serge backsides and issuing an unambiguous command to the Politzei to stop the blue-light bullying.
Won’t happen – Cde Zuma believes he and his cohorts have done nothing wrong.
I think the jogger is concealing the truth; his gesture was actually a grudging tribute to an ageing gentleman’s well proven and astounding prowess. Clearly something other than beer would thus need to be prescribed to remedy the young man’s disillusionment.
Anywhere isn’t the show of amiableness some of the traits of the con artists? Looking at Zuma I am reminded of some passages from the book “The Young Elizabeth, the first 25 years” by Alison Plowden. The passages relate to Henry VIII.
On his coronation, “If you could see how all the world here is rejoicing at the possession of so great a prince. How his life is all their desire, you could not contain your tears for joy. The heavens laugh, the earth exults, all things are full of milk, honey and of nectar! Avarice is expelled the country. Liberality scatters wealth with bounteous hand. Our king does not desire gold or gems or precious metals, but virtue, glory, immortality”.
It is said he “would use himself more familiarly among private persons than the honour of his majesty required”
He was like his grandfather Edward who had fully realised the somewhat cynical observation that the “the common people oftentimes more esteem and take for greater kindness a little courtesy than a great benefit”.
In the words of Thomas More “The king has a way of making every man feel that he is enjoying his special favour, just as the London wives pray before the image of Our Lady by the Tower till each of them believes it is smiling upon her”
But Sir Thomas More saw deeper “that if his head could win the King a castle in France it should not fail to go.”
I rest my case.
waiting on drinks with JZ…is that like tea with Mussolini?
As much as I laughed, I don’t think accusations of Nazism are likely to faze a certain type of African loyalist, to be honest.
@chuma — amazing, nothing is ever really new, is it?
@leon — lovely, wish i had thought of that
I move that we all line the streets the next time a blue light motorcade passes and pay tribute to our constitutional right to the freedom fo speech with a raised one-finger salute. Whay say ?