The “condition” of women and girl children remains repulsive. This is an indictment to humanity as a whole, given that the overall human condition itself is precarious. In her incomparable novel, Changes, Ama Ata Aidoo brilliantly captures the critical challenges confronting females in particular — the conversations of the two main characters, Esi and Opokuya, neatly present the fundamental challenge. I reproduce one of the instructive conversations below:
“How? How could I have done more than I did as a wife and a mother, and still be able to compete on an equal basis with my male colleagues in terms of my output? How can I do more than I’m already doing and compete effectively for promotion, travel opportunities and other side-benefits of the job?” (Esi pondered)
“Esi, Esi, Esi! … What kind of talk is this? Ah. So you gave extra time to your conferences. You competed effectively and got promoted. Now look at what has happened at your marriage. Where does that leave you?” (Responded Opokuya)
“Opokuya, I don’t think I’m beginning to regret anything. But in fact, considering how much I put in my job … sometimes I even take home data to analyse! I never get that much from it, not half as much as those men … and even with the promotion, they passed me over a couple of times … Why is life so hard on the professional African woman?” (Esi)
“Why is life so hard on the non-professional African woman? Eh? Esi, isn’t life even harder for the poor rural and urban African women? Remember it is always harder for some other women somewhere else” (Opokuya)
Indeed, it is “always harder for some other women somewhere else” and even worse for some girl children somewhere else. Some glaring, and disconcerting, facts stand to substantiate Opokuya. For instance, the 2009 Millennium Development Goals Report of the United Nations demonstrates that the ongoing global economic recession is “holding back progress towards gender equality by creating new hurdles to women’s employment”. In this context, the International Labour Organisation (ILO) estimates that “global unemployment in 2009 could reach 6.1% to 7% for men and 6.5% to 7.4% for women, many of whom remain trapped in insecure — often unpaid — jobs”. When it comes to the girl children, the report concludes that, in the developing world in particular, 95 girls are enrolled in primary school for every 100 boys. This is disheartening as we know that the target of eliminating gender disparities in primary and secondary education by 2005 was missed. The report also shows that “girls born into impoverished households or living in rural communities are at a distinct disadvantage in terms of education … gender disparities associated with poverty and rural residency are even more pronounced at the level of secondary education”. Lastly, the report found, unsurprisingly, that young adolescents are more likely to die or experience complications in pregnancy and childbirth than adult women. Moreover, the children of these young mothers have a higher risk of morbidity and mortality. It states that “girls who give birth before the age of 15 are five times more likely to die in childbirth than women in their twenties. Pregnancy early in life contributes to the estimated 70 000 maternal deaths among girls aged 15 to 19 every year”.
Futhi Ntshingila, in her powerful novel Shameless stunningly captures the reality of many “younger” women. Her protagonist, the amazing Thandiwe, narrates the extraordinary challenges of (black) women. She, addressing her counterparts, through the determined Kwena, argues that “some of you would know what I am talking about. You are whores like me; the difference is that in your world you call yourself a junior from a disadvantaged background, a perpetual protégée — always with a highly patronising mentor, most often a man. You have thought about it, squeezing your mentor until he pops for not acknowledging you. He can’t help but resent you. The guilt makes him meaner than he intends to be. So, like a hungry flea, he digs deeper into your skin, sucking your soul. You stay, you have to, otherwise you will lose your illusion of an unreachable dream … ”. We also get informed of how she escaped the potentially devastating injustice that many women go through. Her foster mother, Aunty Muthoni, begs her to escape — Thandiwe became an orphan at an early age. In the middle of the night, at her foster home, Aunty Muthoni says “you have to run Thandi. I will not live with myself if I don’t protect you. I am also going home to Nairobi. I have decided. What happened to me should not happen to any other woman. I am going home to save many, many other women who are killed while they are alive … ”.
The world recently honoured the International Day of No Violence Against Women. In December 10, we will celebrate another International Human Rights Day. It is hard, if not impossible, not to reflect on the condition of women and girl children — the term “human condition” is deployed here along the lines that Hannah Arendt and Amartya Sen have conceptualised it. Clearly, as the data speaks for itself, we — as a people, globally — have a long way to go. The stories of Kwena, Aunty Muthoni, Thandiwe, Opokuya and Esi — or the fifteen-year-old Kambili in Chimamanda Adichie’s Purple Hibiscus or Elizabeth in Bessie Head’s A Question of Power — are just a glimpse to what women and girl children endure daily. The numbers from the UN and ILO are just a glance of what women and girl children face. Women and girl children bear worse forms of hardships even in the hands of so-called loved-ones. Women, especially those in professional employment, perform many other responsibilities that are often underappreciated. The systems and institutions that have to champion the cause of the rights of women and girl children are often found wanting. For instance, in the world where rape is rampant it is incomprehensible, sad actually, that there are hardly facilities for rape counselling. As we approach December 10 again, we — as a global community — have to renew our efforts for recognising the violation of human rights and intensify the interventions to correct such violations or at least sufficiently punish them.
At an individual level, we — especially we men — should start by recognising the injustices we commit, wittingly or unwittingly, to girl children and women broadly. We live in a world that is not fairly structured, a world in which males have significant power. Because of this unfair advantage, we do things that Thandiwe talks about — females are our lifetime protégées and we resent them. This is not to say that all males are bad all the time. The point is that we need to try to reflect more on our actions, words, behaviours and even thoughts. Of course, it is easy to say this — the doing is often a tall order, especially as our terrible deeds normally go unpunished. Women too have some responsibility, at an individual level or collectively. In particular, women need to ensure that the girl child is taken good care of. With the fathers, mothers need to induct the girl children thoroughly and with honesty to this unfair world we inhabit. Girl children have to know the nature of this world, and have the means to navigate the complexities of being a female (and sometimes more challenging for the girl child who is also classified as black). I am not implying that women are not doing these important things, including standing up for themselves and their own and not dragging each other down. I am, however, of the inclination that the world might be a better place if women took charge in a rigorous manner. I imagine a better world, with women in political leadership and shaping efforts for improving the human condition. It seems men have not done well.
One of the promising women I met through my blog, Sarah Henkeman, (how I wish I could meet her in person) once placed the most powerful comment ever made in my blog. She argued that “it’s far better to work for the common good than to use one identity out of the many we possess, to ‘other’ and demonise fellow human beings. Let’s rise. Let’s transcend the boundaries of our minds”. In my life — professional and otherwise — I have met some of the extraordinary women that give me hope for a better world. Some of these extraordinary women have shaped me in unquantifiable ways. Today, I could write/talk the way I am talking/writing. They continue to significantly shape what I do and how I do. For that, I will forever be grateful to them. For the possible injustices I may have visited on any woman or girl child, I am deeply sorry. Life is a journey; self-awareness and self-correction is an important part of the journey. Let us transcend the boundaries of our minds: let us ignite the girl child and honour the woman. We must join Aunty Muthoni to “save many other women who are killed while they are alive”, lest we forfeit in our own peril the unparalleled humanity and the resilient compassion of our mothers, sisters, daughters, grannies, wives, girlfriends and female colleagues.
Let me conclude with an extract from one of timeless poems, by one of the most daring women, Maya Angelou, challenging the world and declaring never to budge:
You may shoot me with your words,
You may cut me with your eyes,
You may kill me with your hatefulness,
But still, like air, I’ll rise.
Out of the huts of history’s shame
I rise
Up from a past that’s rooted in pain
I rise
I’m a black ocean, leaping and wide,
Welling and swelling I bear in the tide.
Leaving behind nights of terror and fear
I rise
Into a daybreak that’s wondrously clear
I rise
Bringing the gifts that my ancestors gave,
I am the dream and the hope of the slave.
I rise …
This entry was posted
on Monday, November 30th, 2009 at 1:30 am and is filed under Lifestyle.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
12 Responses to “World would be a better place if women took charge”
[…] Thought Leader » Vusi Gumede » World would be a better place if women took charge www.thoughtleader.co.za/vusigumede/2009/11/30/acknowledging-challenges-confronting-women-and-girl-children – view page – cached The “condition” of women and girl children remains repulsive. This is an indictment to humanity as a whole, given that the overall human condition itself is precarious. In her incomparable novel,… Read moreThe “condition” of women and girl children remains repulsive. This is an indictment to humanity as a whole, given that the overall human condition itself is precarious. In her incomparable novel, Changes, Ama Ata Aidoo brilliantly captures the critical challenges confronting females in particular — the conversations of the two main characters, Esi and Opokuya, neatly present the fundamental challenge. I reproduce one of the instructive conversations below: “How? How could I have done more than I did as a wife and a mother, and still be able to compete on an equal basis with my male colleagues in terms of my output? How can I do more than I’m already doing and compete effectively for promotion, travel opportunities and other side-benefits of the job?” (Esi pondered) “Esi, Esi, Esi! … What kind of talk is this? Ah. So you gave extra time to your conferences. You competed effectively and got promoted. Now look at what has happened at your marriage. Where does that leave you?” (Responded Opokuya) “Opokuya, I don’t think I’m beginning to regret anything. But in fact, considering how much I put in my job … sometimes I even take home data to analyse! I never get that much from it, not half as much as those men … and even with the promotion, they passed me over a couple of times … Why is life so hard on the professional African woman?” (Esi) “Why is life so hard on the non-professional African woman? Eh? Esi, isn’t life even harder for the poor rural and urban African women? Remember it is always harder for some other women somewhere else” View page […]
@Dr Gumede – great blog. Many promising men and women buckle under the situations presented to them because of their own frailty and the environment that shapes them; while others resist because of acquired(?) positive resilience.
Zimbardo’s ‘The Lucifer effect: how good people turn evil’ explores the Abu Ghraib abuse&torture of prisoners &is compared with an experiment he conducted with (ordinary)students at Stanford University in 1971.
He concludes that ‘[G]ood people don’t rush in to do evil where angels fear to tread; …they start by straying only a small way away from their moral centre, …each successive step down is hardly different, barely noticeable, until it is too late and their behavior is shocking and may even be awesome or awful’. I think this applies to many abusive men and women.
Importantly, he suggests that it is time to ‘…go up the explanatory chain from person to situation to system’. Similarly, some feminist scholars insist that we need to look also at the intersection of social phenomena such as race, class, gender etc. Taken together it is clear that individual men need to examine themselves, but also that we need to change the social environment that creates the situations in which individuals do not/cannot/will not resist the ‘…powerful forces toward compliance, conformity and obedience’.
There’s hope:’…the very same situation that can inflame the “hostile imagination” in those who become perpetrators of evil can inspire the “heroic imagination”…’. A matter of critical mass?
Thought provoking Natate Gumede.It’s not a question of male or female.its a question of our ability to transcend the boundaries that continue to enslave us, as a people,a society & a nation.It’s about realising that there’s power in numbers.That together, male & female, we can shape our society & make it a better place for the common good of all.
I recently read (can’t remember the source) that about 42% of SA families are single-mother headed. Only a day or two later, some nice man on talk radio said women should raise the children at home and jobs should be reserved for men. I can’t imagine what the single-parent families would live on…especially since getting any maintenance is so difficult for so many single mothers. Talk radio (in this case SAFM) can be defamatory and inflammatory; decent programming would be better!
Statistics about the percentage of women in top management are a ridiculous waste of time; most mothers would prefer to give the top job a miss in order to be a better parent. They would like equal pay for equal labour, it’s true, but don’t necessarily want to be promoted through the glass ceiling. They can’t find wives to organise their dry cleaning.
I generalise: women are natural workers, but sometimes micro manage. Men are usually delighted to leave someone else to do the work.
An anecdote: a DoT director was offered a cup of tea by a colleague when we were working over a long weekend. He made a huge fuss over the fact that she is multi-skilled and thought himself hysterically funny. I’d have put arsenic in the tea!
Excellent article Dr. Vusi. I’ve always wondered if the world would really be a better place if women took charge. Would the world have experienced World War I and II, Cold War and many others after that. But then i came to realise that women are capable of the same sort of violence that the world has endured under the leadership of man,they are no less different than we are. The reality now is that it was shaped by a “genius” who wrote the bible and koran amongst others for them to be so oppressed. We should also acknowledge that strides have been made in putting women in positions of power and if am not mistaken there are about 14 countries around the world that have women as presidents or heads of state, so such strides should really be acknowledged nd also taking into consideration that those women led countries haven’t suddenly improved from where they were before.
The next article Dr. Vusi may it please acknowledge the contribution of men to this world.
Interesting piece doc, i happen to refer to this blog on my recent post on blog spot-am afraid some might view me as a non-believer, books like the bible potrays some kind of pernicious teachings and counsel that over the years has encouraged some kind of abuse against women. In order to eliminate ignorance and mitigate the rising tide of abuse against women-i think our religous leaders got to accept and treat both sexes as equal as lots of people base their decision on what these religous leaders say.
vusi this is a subject very to my heart ! when teenagers indulge in premarital sex ,girls are always the ones left to reap the rewards they have to stay at home and look after the babies facing the challenges of early motherhood,when mothers have babies girls are always the ones told to stay at home and look after after the younger siblings,when men go to work in the mines they women stay behind and wait for them,only for the men to return with viruses,when men start being violent women and children are always the victims there are countless examples i can narrate but look at the world now ! despite all mothers have managed to raise children and better .mothers have managed to keep societies going,abused mothers have raised leaders and scientists ,abused mothers have kept families from falling ,protected their children from the injustices of society ,they have been the first teachers .what would the world be without women .the world would surely be a better place if women took charge
Bridgeman Ndelemane on January 11th, 2010 at 2:26 pm
I may sound extremly naieve or even simple, but if you would allow me ask that question again. There is enough for all of us. so, where is the problem? Is it the human nature? International community relationship, education, cultures? If we manage to adress this question, I gues we would be heading twoards healing all the past wounds!!!
All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.
profile
Dr Vusi Gumede has post-graduate qualifications in economics and public policy, among others. He worked for the South African government for about 10 years, as an advisor, economist, policy analyst, etc. Prior to that, he was in the academic/research environment. He has remained in the academic/research environment, including having been a visiting scholar/fellow for various universities abroad and other international/overseas institutions, lecturing at the Graduate School of Public and Development Management at the University of Witwatersrand in South Africa, publishing in international and South African journals, contributing chapters in books, authoring working papers and policy briefs, and so on. Dr Gumede serves in a number of governance and advisory structures, including as a Trustee for the Southern Africa Trust. He consults for numerous institutions, including some South African government agencies/departments and the United Nations Development Programme.
Dr Vusi Gumede is presently an Associate Professor in Development Studies at the University of Johannesburg in South Africa.
Nuruddin Farah, one of the extraordinary novelists of our times, succinctly captured -- in his novel entitled Secrets -- the beginnings of Somalia's c...
In what is recorded as his last speech, the extraordinary Anton Muziwakhe Lembede told the gathering, at Leake Hall in Soweto, June 1947, that "the hi...
The previous decade was rough, at many levels. This new decade, the 2010s, brings some hope. However, the risks remain on the upside -- politically, g...
The world we live in remains a disturbingly dangerous and very fragile place, largely because of our own making. Amin Maalouf opens his provocative bo...
There are many things that Africans do which give Africa and Africans a bad name or rather there are things that folks with black skin do which tarnis...
[…] Thought Leader » Vusi Gumede » World would be a better place if women took charge www.thoughtleader.co.za/vusigumede/2009/11/30/acknowledging-challenges-confronting-women-and-girl-children – view page – cached The “condition” of women and girl children remains repulsive. This is an indictment to humanity as a whole, given that the overall human condition itself is precarious. In her incomparable novel,… Read moreThe “condition” of women and girl children remains repulsive. This is an indictment to humanity as a whole, given that the overall human condition itself is precarious. In her incomparable novel, Changes, Ama Ata Aidoo brilliantly captures the critical challenges confronting females in particular — the conversations of the two main characters, Esi and Opokuya, neatly present the fundamental challenge. I reproduce one of the instructive conversations below: “How? How could I have done more than I did as a wife and a mother, and still be able to compete on an equal basis with my male colleagues in terms of my output? How can I do more than I’m already doing and compete effectively for promotion, travel opportunities and other side-benefits of the job?” (Esi pondered) “Esi, Esi, Esi! … What kind of talk is this? Ah. So you gave extra time to your conferences. You competed effectively and got promoted. Now look at what has happened at your marriage. Where does that leave you?” (Responded Opokuya) “Opokuya, I don’t think I’m beginning to regret anything. But in fact, considering how much I put in my job … sometimes I even take home data to analyse! I never get that much from it, not half as much as those men … and even with the promotion, they passed me over a couple of times … Why is life so hard on the professional African woman?” (Esi) “Why is life so hard on the non-professional African woman? Eh? Esi, isn’t life even harder for the poor rural and urban African women? Remember it is always harder for some other women somewhere else” View page […]
(Report abuse)