« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

President Jacob Zuma is going to have to draw a line in the sand and decide where loyalty ends and common sense begins in his, as well as the African National Congress’s, approach to the ANCYL and its president, Julius Malema.

After yesterday’s racist tirade at the University of Johannesburg the ANC has yet to decide on whether or not to meet with its youth league president. Spokesman Ishmael Mnisi said on Wednesday that the party was always in touch with the league, but had not decided whether to talk to Malema about this particular matter.

In layman’s terms the ruling party that forms the government that is in charge of all South Africans can’t decide whether racist attacks on certain of their citizens needs to be dealt with by them.

Perhaps at the next election they may wish to clarify before the vote that if the ANC are elected as the next government then they see their role as strictly overseeing the needs and requirements of the ANC membership. This in turn will mean that the remaining 45 odd million South Africans are going to need a separate government to deal with their issues.

Pursuant to a declaration along those lines the ANC will be more than welcome to focus on purely party matters from what will then be fewer seats than those currently held by the ID.

In the meanwhile, as they are the government and ruling party in charge of all South Africans — while clearly in desperate need of a few tutorials on what distinguishes a constitutional democracy like South Africa from the anarchy that is Somalia — perhaps they might want to consider what the implications are going to be if everyone starts behaving like Malema and certain other leaders.

He is after all a role model to the masses.

If every interest group that goes to make up the aggregate of what we consider our masses starts calling for violence and resorts to name-calling against the ANC or the government every time it feels so inclined, what will be the response?

As things stand you can’t even scratch your ear with your middle finger if the president’s convoy is passing by in case you get picked up, have a brown bag put over your head and interrogated to see that you aren’t endangering our leader.

Yet when the leader of one of the biggest groups in the country — the ANCYL — calls the leader of the opposition a Satanist and the head of the ID a woman that no normal man could marry, the ANC can’t work out whether to deal with it or not.

The hypocrisy is overwhelming.

When Malema called for white people to be shot and accused them of being rapists somewhere, somehow, someone surely asked the question of how much longer this is going to be allowed to carry on before it turns on those who don’t deal with it.

For example if, once again, other groups followed the youth league president’s fine lead and called upon their followers to shoot other races would the government expect the police to have to go in and arrest them and if so how would they be able to distinguish it from Malema’s case without arresting him?

Or is Malema simply above the law?

As we saw earlier today the police are changing to military ranks to try and instil discipline.

That’s nonsense.

You fight corruption and crime by setting examples at the top and clamping down on slackness at the bottom. The same way you ensure that a culture of lawlessness does not arise by giving example after example of leaders and politicians who disregard the rule of law as if it is some kind of irritant.

A disregard which seems to permeate every level of our society.

What is going to happen when South African society, using our leaders as their example, start disregarding the laws that they consider inappropriate to themselves? Is the government going to try another do as I say not as I do number?

At that point in time the very system that maintains law and order will, as a result of their own conduct, become ineffective in dealing with the society that it is meant to regulate and the people who are responsible for undermining it by gross disregard, will be the ones calling out the military.

In a country where so much anger exists over the perceived failure of service delivery, coupled to a culture of violence that arises from way back when the last thing that anyone would expect is that those in charge of the country would do anything to jeopardise a criminal justice system which they may well need in the not-too-distant future.




Related Posts

25 Responses to “ANC’s placating Malema at its own peril”

I seem to recall certain of your family members and commentators kindly requesting that you change your tactics and vote for that smart auntie and the ID. Now see, if there were more Patricias and less Juliuses, we might actually get something done instead of spending all day slaving, complaining and scratching our ears but still travelling sideways or backwards.

The ANC has now become so broad a church that everyone’s miniscule opinion is to be defended if that person is (known to be - sorry Chumani, you were too quiet beforehand obviously) one of the membaz. Hence the defences of freedom of speech and ignorance (’these songs are from before he was born’) and innumerable instances of putting personal interest before either party interest or public service.

But whatever. If you carry on enough you’ll become like a regular white person (whatever that is) and start to just enjoy complaining, all the time being fully aware that you’re just being a racist whinger and should eff off back to Europe or wherever.

(Report abuse)

Kit on March 11th, 2010 at 2:25 pm

Just another failure to act by our government/president. They don’t need to react anymore, there is no need. It seems as if we expect some sort of revolution every time they mess up, but the truth is they just laugh it off.

(Report abuse)

Stephen Browne on March 11th, 2010 at 3:57 pm

Traps,

Where do YOU draw the line? To what depth of depravity and disregard for law does the ANC have to sink to lose your (putative) vote? Are we there yet?

Can we hope that your sensitivities as a lawyer have been so outraged that your sentimental attachment to what you wanted to believe about the ANC has resulted in an epiphany? The non-racial ANC you–and all sane people!–would like to support does not exist.

What does exist is a morally and intellectually corrupt ‘Lego version’ of the Soviet model where the ends always justify the means. Hence, Winnie can praise Nelson on one stage and trash him on another without being conscious of any deviousness or betrayal on her part.

Zuma can call for his machine gun and Juju Amin can call for students to ‘kill the boer’ with complete equanimity by claiming that what both songs say isn’t what they REALLY say… Yeah. Right.

Let’s see how long it would take anyone else to be hauled up on Human Rights charges for singing “Kill Zuma” or “Kill Malema”, never mind calling for a general bloodbath by singing “Kill the Zulu, the Khosa, the Pedi”, etc.
What defense would be offered on behalf of a white or coloured person singing such a song: “What? Can’t you blacks take a joke? We didn’t mean “kill” literally! It’s a metaphor for, for…” Exactly. “Kill” is not a metaphor for anything; it’s a command.

(Report abuse)

Siobhan on March 11th, 2010 at 7:22 pm

At the rate he’s collecting lawsuits, Mr Malema is going to spend a larger proportion of his time explaining himself to the courts than he will spend rabble-rousing. His problem is that the courts are not mindless youths who hang on his every word….and his bravado about not respecting the Equality Court may yet earn him 90 days in jug for contempt of court

(Report abuse)

RogerP on March 11th, 2010 at 7:55 pm

I say let the muppet (Jube Jube)talk. Give him his platforms, splash it in the media, encourage him, applaud him even for the emperors clothes are falling off rather rapidly and revealing the racist dunce for what he and those he represents really are. His rantings are serving the purpose of raising the debate on what it really means to be South African. This is the time when we will define our future as South Africans. I have faith that most South Africans are fairly level headed and will show their disgust with the present leadership at the next elections…As the saying goes..give a man enough rope….

(Report abuse)

Witbooi on March 11th, 2010 at 8:03 pm

and now some big wig in the ANC has been charged with drunken driving earlier on this morning in Cape Town. A lucky escape for whoever it was lined up to meet with him next. It seems there were attempts by the ”membaz” to hush things up. But I’m just whinging and enjoying it.@Kit

(Report abuse)

Egg on March 11th, 2010 at 8:37 pm

Traps: Bravo, Bravo for this brilliant appraisal of the current sorry situation in the country. Just when one is about to give up hope there comes a courageous voice of sanity and wisdom and hopefully someone may heed this clarion call to sanity. Why this resounding silence on the part of the powers that be is a source of great dismay to all of us who had wished this great country the success that it promised to be.
The bizare news this morning that a senior member of the party in power shamelessly defended the idiotic and inflammatory behaviour of the ANCYL leader, and that a law enforcement officer [presumably sworn to abide by/defend the constitutional principle of equal treatment without fear or favour] blatantly refused to process the charge sheet against a drunk/drive party member is mind boggling. As a lawyer you must have found it incredible; so much for upholding law and order. Where are the concerted voices of concerned citizens on whose behalf the leadership is entrusted with power to lead the country? Judging from much of the daily comments in the forum the emphasis appears to be on trivia and counter accusations rather intelligent debates about the sad story of national affairs that afflicts the society.
Thank you and the small like-minded people for keeping up the hope.

-Joe Manyoni, Canada.

(Report abuse)

Joe Manyoni, Canada on March 11th, 2010 at 8:59 pm

Ja generaal!

(Report abuse)

Michel on March 11th, 2010 at 9:01 pm

They made him abouve the law by not blaming him for his somewhat messed up statements in teh media.

(Report abuse)

Akanyang Merementsi on March 12th, 2010 at 5:54 am

great piece.

(Report abuse)

gph on March 12th, 2010 at 7:31 am

this is what has taken down most african countries.a buffoon appears and the masses cheer him on.this is how idi amin and bokassa were created and this is how they ruined their countries.what shocks me most about malema are the people prepared to cheer him on.welcome to the banana republic

(Report abuse)

p.kaitakirwa on March 12th, 2010 at 7:53 am

At some point the shit will hit the fan. Who will bear the brunt?

(Report abuse)

Panchetta on March 12th, 2010 at 9:02 am

Well said Michael. Pres. Zuma’s response to a question by a newsman this morning regarding Malema’s comments - he burst out laughing - is outrageous. He forgets that he represents us all. Why must a businessman who plays a song with some insult to Nelson Mandela get fired and accused of racism, but the leader of ANCYL can sing of killing SA citizens and it gets laughed off. How do we define ‘hate speech’? That is illegal in this country - or does that only apply to some?

(Report abuse)

Janine on March 12th, 2010 at 9:14 am

This is the usual Ju Ju trick! Embark on another outrageous course of action to detract from previous outrageous behaviour that led you into a real quagmire, even in ANC circles. We all know the details pertaining to what was “previously on the Ju Ju show” – the one that detailed the making into a millionaire of our Ju Ju “! The oven was just too hot so his PR” machine - well oiled and orchestrated – snapped into action and a deliberate distraction was hastily organized…. one that wouldn’t upset the highest leadership of the ANC too much if at all – who cares if the ordinary citizens of the country, particularly farmers, whites in general, opposition leadership and other “dispensable” are upset – just as long as his buddies in the ANC NEC, etc are okay with him! The heat is off for Ju Ju where it counts – the oven is cooler for him in ANC circles so why should he care?

(Report abuse)

Rose Morrow on March 12th, 2010 at 9:18 am

The ANC has repeatedly shown that it has no respect for the Constitution or the citizens of this country. A raised finger to the president results in arrest and police abuse. Death threats against citizens by the president’s protégé results in introspective shuffling of feet. We need a new government: this one has lost the way.

(Report abuse)

Bill Rogers on March 12th, 2010 at 9:37 am

As I’ve said before - “Welcome to Africa!”

(Report abuse)

Yusuf Magombo on March 12th, 2010 at 10:44 am

More and more Malema in his brazen and confrontation style resembles old style extremists like PW Botha who gained great popularity among Afrikaners in 1964 with statements like: “I am one of those who believe that there is no permanent home for even a section of the Bantu in the white area of South Africa and the destiny of South Africa depends on this essential point. If the principle of permanent residence for the black man in the area of the white is accepted then it is the beginning of the end of civilisation as we know it in this country.” Of course Malema is a better man than the ruthless and closed-minded Botha but we should be careful of how such Botha-like-populism and Botha-like-statements about violence can bend the state and her people to violence.

(Report abuse)

John EveryMan on March 12th, 2010 at 11:55 am

Well said @Siobhan. @RogerP I hope you’re right. In fact, well said everyone. It’s a huge relief to read so many people talking sense - phew!

(Report abuse)

Janine on March 12th, 2010 at 1:00 pm

Julius appears to be sharing what the party actually believes to be the truth. Some time back then deputy minister of mining Lulu Xingwana made it clear that her role was to “right the wrongs of 350 years of oppression” she went on, uncensored as minister of agriculture to suggest the sate just take land – Julius is articulating exactly this sentiment but without the gloss over. We are just too scared to face up to the facts - white people are tolerated, not welcome in South Africa… get used to it.

(Report abuse)

ToniBenoni on March 12th, 2010 at 2:49 pm

JM’s job is to explain to protesting students who demand free education why the ANC cannot give it to them. He should make whatever excuses he likes, as long as they lie at the ANC’s feet. JZ’s job is to apologise profusely for not being able to keep an election promise. He should make whatever excuses he likes, as long as they lie at the ANC’s feet. One thing is certain, it is not the fault of white students that this has happened; targeting them merely shows that too few ANCYL protesters are just not bright enough to understand cause and effect. So why should they be considered for tertiary education at all?

(Report abuse)

MLH on March 12th, 2010 at 5:13 pm

Whilst it’s quite normal for politicians to address university students, one might expect the ANC to ‘deploy’ the best and the brightest in that direction. For me there’s some kind of incongruity in ‘deploying’ Julius to speak on University campuses. But then again as the old saying goes: “Empty barrels …”

(Report abuse)

Neil Parker on March 13th, 2010 at 7:25 am

It will take at least 40 years for this underlying hatred of whites to disappear. Too many leaders in the ANC are unwilling to “forgive and forget” what happened in the past. The likes of “JM” comes to mind. They are hell-bent on extracting revenge. A victory earned in blood, will only suffice. Even if their actions result in the total destruction of South Africa, this bears no consequence. Hence, the beginning of the demeaning of Mandela. The cloak of protection is beginning to wear thin. Whites beware!

(Report abuse)

Pieinthesky on March 13th, 2010 at 11:39 am

Pieinthesky - I get your point - it would be great if we could wave a magic wand to wipe out all the injustices, pain and loss of loved ones from the hearts and minds of all the people who suffered under apartheid and miraculously brought each of them to a place of forgiveness and forgetfulness. But then I think of just how very difficult it is to “forgive and forget” when, having been married for forty five years you discover your husband has been having and affair for fifteen of those years. It is not a personal experience but a very close friend is in just those shoes. She is a deeply committed Christian and every fibre of her being is crying out for her to forget and move on -but that betrayed heart and mind, three years on, just won’t let her do it - and she cannot find trust anywhere in her soul. It sounds dramatic and it is - easy to say forgive, forget and move on if you haven’t stood in those shoes…. it would be great if we could all forgive and forget and move on, including those of us who have suffered the loss of loved ones to brutal crimes committed in recent years. It’s a tough one - necessary and best for the country if we could - but damn hard for sure.

(Report abuse)

Rose Morrow on March 15th, 2010 at 2:20 pm

@pieinthesky

You said, ‘It will take at least 40 years for this underlying hatred of whites to disappear. Too many leaders in the ANC are unwilling to “forgive and forget” what happened in the past.’

In the 1970s I was uprooted from the ‘last outpost of the British Empire’ (Durban) where I had not learned to speak a word of Afrikaans and deposited in an Afrikaans-medium school after my late father took a transfer on promotion to where there was no English-medium school. I was subjected to abuse and vilification at the hands of my fellow primary school pupils because of the hatred for the Rooinek
handed down from generation to generation, more than seventy years after the Boer War. How much longer do you think hatred for whites will linger among the black population if irresponsible elements persist in fanning racism and promoting violence?

I am under no illusion that all in South Africa will forgive and forget the atrocity which was Apartheid within a hundred years let alone forty. The best we can hope for is that the Constitution will be respected and the law obeyed so that a peaceful and integrated community can evolve in due course.

(Report abuse)

Bill Rogers on March 15th, 2010 at 5:01 pm

Bill Rogers - that is what I call facing the reality. Very wise! There are always consequences for actions - good and bad. Even if a victim’s family forgives the perpetrator for murdering their loved one - that murderer still has to serve a jail sentence, even if he or she is remorseful, repentant and begging forgiveness. It will take time to heal the wounds, pain and injustice visited on the millions during apartheid. However, it doesn’t help when the provocative, self-serving Malema sings very inflamatory hate songs to divert attention away from his ill gotten millions and the dubious position in which he finds himself. Equally it doesn’t help when self serving previously advantaged make a fuss about a street name or town name that is to be changed because the person it honours slaughtered/denigrated/insulted or enslaved the indigenous people of the area. There is a debt to be paid by the previously advantaged, but not with more lives lost in brutal, horrific circumstances -this will only create more pain and hatred amongst another group and they will need another one hundred years to get over their pain. The country can never rise from the ashes in those circumstances - as the saying goes “an eye for an eye will leave everyone blind”. We as South Africans really do have to stop being self serving and start wanting what is best for our country.

(Report abuse)

Rose Morrow on March 16th, 2010 at 10:43 am

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

We have put a word limit of 250 words on all your comments


words left

profile
Mike Trapido is editor of NewsTime

By trade a criminal attorney he is now a full time editor and journalist.

He was born in Johannesburg and attended HA Jack and Highlands North High Schools.

He married Robyn in 1984 (Mrs Traps, aka "the government") and has three sons (who all look suspiciously like her ex-boss).

He was a counsellor on the JCCI for a year around 1992.

His passions include Derby County, Blue Bulls, Orlando Pirates, Proteas and Springboks.

He takes Valium in order to cope with Bafana Bafana's results.

Tell a Friend Technorati RSS
more posts
Themba Maseko, the spokesperson for the Cabinet, today confirmed that the government is committed to accommodating the views expressed during public h...
Professor Steven Friedman in an article in Business Day says that the media has it wrong about secrecy law’s victims and that the failure of the med...
On Saturday, Pat Boone, a conservative political commentator, Christian activist, writer and preacher, put the entire American cat population among th...
As the National Prosecuting Authority bask in the afterglow of having obtained a conviction against former top cop Jackie Selebi in Johannesburg on We...
Once upon a time in a land at the southern tip of Africa, there lived a people so adept at making the rest of the world scratch their heads until thei...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 967992
Total comments 19745
Michael's tags
advertisement
    Mail & Guardian Online Headlines
  • National
  • Business
  • Africa
  • World
  • Sport
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator