« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

All the provincial leadership structures of the ANC Youth League have been reported to stand behind their besieged president, Julius Malema. They believe their man is under attack from unscrupulous characters who are involved in clandestine power struggles to determine who will lead the ANC in 2012 when it holds its next big elections.

It is a good thing that the ANCYL is a tight and solid organisation that gives unconditional support to its leader.

Unity is strength.

But it is funny that my reading of this development collapsed into what I consider that “aha!” experience in life when things fall out of place. I was suddenly able to relive the powerful moment of “I told you so” when a young child refuses to do as they are told only to end up burning their fingers.

I do not think the provincial structures of the ANCYL clearly understand the meaning of their stance in this Malema issue. Of course any leader, no matter his age, who spouts the radical politics of “nationalisation” and threatens the interests of capitalism is going to be a target.

Those who see him as a risk to their material interests are going to leave no stone unturned in both “exposing” his follies and making sure he goes down. This is what happened to Patrice Lumumba in the Democratic Republic of the Congo in the 1960s, for instance.

There is more to this Malema issue than meets the eye.

But the issue at hand, for me, is for the youth leadership, who are the custodians of the aspirations and hopes of the future, to clearly understand those subtle, often unconsciously unidentified discrepancies between what you do and what you say.

What the youth leadership of this country needs to understand is that they cannot afford to settle for quick-fix solutions. We expect young people, especially leaders, to understand the deeper level of their decisions and not be afraid to take a stance that will be at variance with popular figures in powerful positions.

I am not suggesting that Malema is guilty of any crime for pulling himself up by his boot straps or accumulating wealth that he cannot explain. But the fact that a young leader has a larger-than-life personality, speaks truth to those who wield economic power, is confident and very popular does not, necessarily, make him a great leader.

These are not essential qualities for a future leader of a country.

These are just traits that make up the personality of the man but tell us very little about his character. The young leaders of this country cannot afford to focus on the personality of a leader and thus forget the character. This will ultimately make the chickens come home to roost.

If a so-called leader uses political strategies and public-relations tactics to say what people expect him to say, to whip up emotions with rhetoric while his character is fundamentally flawed, then there is a big problem.

If people cannot match what a leader says to what he does, his whole character will be haunted by duplicity and insincerity. And this will, inevitably, breed distrust and lack of confidence.

In the long run, his sayings or utterances will be perceived as manipulative and some people may lose faith in his organisation and withdraw their support.

It simply makes no difference how good your public speaking is or how well you articulate the ideals of a 1955 document that are not government policy; if there is little trust and your actions do not match what you say, there is no foundation for future success.

People will always be judged by what they do more than what they say.

Yet sometimes leaders who are very good with the technique of pressing the right emotional buttons do get away with murder. It would be ridiculous for a well-fed man who lives in a mansion and drives around in expensive cars to tell the poor that he cares for them.

Much as the masses are gullible, you will be judged by what you do with … er, your money to improve the lives of the disadvantaged. In the short run, the youth leadership has done the right thing to rally around and give unconditional support to their president.

But this is a quick-fix approach that is not a permanent solution.

Eventually, if there is no deep integrity and fundamental character strength, the people will reveal their colours and failure and self-destruction may plague the ANCYL.

Youth leaders must be an example of all that is good, admirable and, above all, people of integrity.




Related Posts

13 Responses to “The Juju joyride…”

Are you saying that Malema has no integrity or am i reading it wrong and out of context?
Either way this was a great piece-thought provoking

(Report abuse)

KAGISO on March 12th, 2010 at 2:24 pm

Unconditional support a good thing?

I fail to see how any politician or leader can be encouraged to do the right thing when their support is unconditional.

It is the unconditional support that is enjoyed by the ANC that has allowed corruption to flourish and service delivery to founder.

How would a sports team perform if its selectors gave unconditional support to existing players, when they are kicking own-goals in every match?

(Report abuse)

Gavin on March 12th, 2010 at 2:25 pm

Malume Memela

I always prefer to remind people about what they have written or said in the past, may it be a year or two ago, it doesn’t matter, more particularly about issues which are very close to my heart, in this case, a subject about phony intellectuals who are against/who question the achievements of black people.
This is what you had said in the blog post titled, “Black writers, white readers”

“The last ten years have been marked by a strange phenomenon in black writing: a visible and negative literary portrayal of the black experience and critical assault on black identity and achievement….

But black writers have, unwittingly, become enemies of everything that their people fought for.

Instead, their allegiance overlooks the celebration of freedom and democracy to promote pseudo-critical intellectual stances that supposedly speak truth to power.

This approach, influenced by a desire to reach a white readership — instead of growing a black audience — needs serious critical examination, especially from the black world itself.”

http://www.thoughtleader.co.za/sandilememela/2009/11/30/black-celebrity-authors-for-the-white-market/

(Report abuse)

Siphiwo Siphiwo on March 12th, 2010 at 3:38 pm

“Youth leaders must be an example of all that is good, admirable and, above all, people of integrity.”

I guess the problem is that a lot of the youth thinks that Mr Malema *is* an example of all that is good and admirable.

What shall we do about that, Mr ANC Man?

(Report abuse)

PeterH on March 12th, 2010 at 3:40 pm

At least you have tried to be a bit objective. Look Malema is a great leader in making, I personally used to go by what the media, particularly the print media says about him. This led me to get irritated about him, thinking he is a dull amongs dulls. Not untill I listened to him politiking, did I ever looked up to him as a highly advanced young man who approach politics with less complexities.

I was there at University of Johanesburg where it is alleged he was inciting blacks to kill boers and qaoted as having sung “Kill the Boers, they are rapists”.

I can confirm to you that, like many students who came to listen to him, journerlists included, everybody was moved by his logic on unity of the progressive student movement, life style audit, nationalisation and why he is being attacked. One afrikaaner journerlist was so hurt with the harsh logic behind Malema’s adress on issues she could not hold back her tears. Black journerlist were also exposed to the delight of students. At the end of the day, journerlist had nothing bad to write about Malema except concentrating on twisting the songs lyrics. I can confirm that they probably did so out of frustration - hence I challenge all to retrieve the lyrics where Malema says “boers are rapists”, its all desperate lies. Becuase you a bit of a rational writer, go and investigate if it is true that Malema’s lyrics talked about rapists

(Report abuse)

Obzino Latino on March 12th, 2010 at 4:05 pm

There are great leaders and despicable people of all races. Heroism and villainy are equally distributed. If Mr Memela’s article was attacking the leadership or Barack Obama or the business acumen of Phutuma Nhleko, possibly Siphiwo Siphiwo’s response would make sense. As it is, defending someone who is less than a great leader is the equivalent of a rugby stadium of white people cheering Jimmy Abbott (a hooligan and a barbarian) as a hero, which praise the Lord has never happened and I hope will never happen. The message of the blog is a good one - great black leaders - like those I mentioned - are great because they are great. They are more than proof that the same standards of leadership should be applied to all - not a highly lowered standard in the interests of racial solidarity.

(Report abuse)

Mark Robertson on March 12th, 2010 at 7:18 pm

OK Obzino, so what did the lyrics say? I hope this is not about semantics?

(Report abuse)

Oscar on March 13th, 2010 at 8:40 am

“Those who see him as a risk to their material interests are going to leave no stone unturned in both ‘exposing’ his follies and making sure he goes down”

I disagree. But I’m glad ‘exposing’ was put in inverted commas, because it’s not journalists who are exposing his follies — Julius is doing a wonderful job of exposing his own dim-wittedness in virtually every public statement he makes.

And Obzino: Just because a racist, immature “leader” makes the occasional good speech is no reason to suddenly honour him as a “highly advanced young man who approaches politics with less complexities”. Your post exposes the very contradiction about Julius Malema: that he is NOT an advanced young man, but on the rare occasion where he does make sense, we are so shocked and bewildered that we suddenly sing his praises and rethink our opinions about him. Ag, please!

(Report abuse)

s pillay on March 13th, 2010 at 11:18 pm

@KAGISO if this is thought provoking; then why do you have a problem thinking, lol bro no disrespect meant in any way, but surely you can understand what the author is getting at.

(Report abuse)

Mondavo_H on March 14th, 2010 at 11:55 am

The ANC Youth league is a misnomer and have strayed from the ANC of old, just as the current ANC has done. In any case these structures within the ANC were great appendages as wheels of the ANC liberation movement, but are no longer relevant.

What we have now is seperate political movements all sharing a piece of the ANC brand. The so-called tripartite alliance is a case in point.

The ANC Youth League is far right to the ANC and behaves much like the PAC when they had a bit of balls. If they were to take their outlandish and childish ‘policies’ to the elections as an indepedent political party, they would no doubt end up the same way.

The real pretender is the ANC who gather all to their bosem so that they can remain in power. The leaders of these leaguesw and unions get their piece of the pie.

(Report abuse)

Panchetta on March 14th, 2010 at 6:43 pm

The Honourable President accepts that Mr Malema is a firebrand and that he is doing what Mr Mandela was doing in the 1950s, now that’s very worrying coming from the leader of a party that is in power. It says that this party probably does not understand the difference between the politics of being in power in 2010 (being in power for more than 15 years) and the politics of a time when the then ruling party required firebrands like Mandela to get a whisper of the message. I cannot say that I know Mr Malema well but the little that I have learnt about him is worrying (including the comparison drawn by the Honourable President between him and the young firebrand that Mr Mandela was in the 1950s)

… and, yes, like any good politician, he is reported as having said something sensible at one or other time, I don’t think that that elevates him to a position of a good leader. The comparison with the conduct of someone at the prime of apartheid and someone who belongs to a party that has ruled this country for 15 years, questions whether the party intends growing from resistance to power.

This is not a personal attack, it only seeks to ask whether we should celebrate a youth leader in 2010 who is said to be politicking like youth leaders in the 1950s

(Report abuse)

Fani Dingiswayo on March 15th, 2010 at 12:11 pm

Good points from Obzino Latino. I was also at the UJ address. It was not just the white afrikaner journo who cried that got to me, it was more the way the students were shook to see a man so derided make so much sense on a subject that many pretend to know.

Malema himself always says that when it comes to debating, they cant touch him. That is why all we ever read about is the “lies” from City press, M&G and Sunday Times

(Report abuse)

Jojo on March 15th, 2010 at 12:55 pm

There is a serious lack of credible and sincere leadership in our country if not the whole of Africa.
The issue of Nationalisation is a burning one that does not need a compromised Populist who can’t tell his mouths from his backside.His brain will explode .But then We have communists who rock to meetings driving AMGs.WE are so totally screwed.Large corporations will continue to exploit our resources.Far-away countries will own us in our own land.I have mixed feelings of tragedy and hope when I think of Zimbabwe.In a world controlled by Ruthless Emperials, devided as Africans we stand no chance.Is it a coincidence that The President was invited by the Queen when The Puppet that is Malema was screaming Nationalisation.Yes;He might be controlled by an Interest group in the
ANC,the bigger picture is that we are still economically enslaved.I dream of a day that a true African Leader who loves his People comes.Currently we are not focusing but are like crabs struggling to climb out of a bucket=Hypocricy and double standards.Every man for himself God for us all!Why are the small political parties not bonding to form 1 cohesive unit against the Giant that is the ANC? Interest groups.Time will come when conscience shall dawn that even Old Magogos will not cast emotive votes no matter how many packets of boerewors they get.Viva freedom!Long live Humanity!

(Report abuse)

Gentlefurry on March 15th, 2010 at 11:53 pm

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

We have put a word limit of 250 words on all your comments


words left

profile
Sandile Memela grew up in Soweto where he was groomed to live 'the life of the mind.'
He believes in freedom of expression and respects the right of those who do not agree with him.
He has worked as an editor, journalist, columnist and advertising strategist.
At the moment, he is a government funk.
Tell a Friend Technorati RSS
more posts
Recently, we had the privilege to witness what could be called a catfight between two legendary women. The one, Nadira Naipaul -- a writer -- had t...
The most depressing part of the 50th anniversary of the Sharpeville massacre wasn't the political mud-slinging between the two leading former liberati...
The deep rumbles of discontent that have exploded into violence and property destruction teach us clearly that the government has not, exactly, succee...
It is inconceivable that the soccer fraternity would demand Bafana Bafana be featured in the Fifa 2010 World Cup final without proving themselves. ...
My intuitive connection to friends, rivals, enemies and colleagues in the media tells me that many of the powerful ones will curse me after they have ...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 162560
Total comments 4092
Sandile's tags
advertisement
    Mail & Guardian Online Headlines
  • National
  • Business
  • Africa
  • World
  • Sport
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator