« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

Almost from the moment the rag-tag gaggle of erstwhile freedom fighters took over the reins of power — and, boy, did they love that power, like a kid who had just got his driver’s licence and was put behind the wheel of a Ferrari — they realised that, even under someone of the statesmanship and stature of Nelson Mandela, they would be incapable of running South Africa without their hands being held all the way by the private sector.

That’s fair enough — and not uncommon among countries emerging from autocratic rule. Fundamentally, it’s a great idea and has worked well in most other circumstances. Not in SA though. That’s not because of the idea, but because of the mindset of dependence and the gimme-gimme culture it has bred.

Along with a small number of people involved in the hand-holding processes — I was communication director for Business Against Crime which was born precisely of a cry for help from none other than Mandela himself in 1996 — we warned against government shirking its responsibilities, leaving all the hard work to the private sector and claiming all the kudos for the work of others when it came to election time and posturing on the platforms of propagandist popularity.

The fact that this has happened with unabashed brazen ballsiness not only proves the point, but has become a culture that believes freebies are the deserved right of everyone with the slightest smidgeon of power, from crooked cops and dirty directors through miscreant mayors and perverted premiers up the scruffy echelons of our kakistocracy to the likes of Julius Malema, Jimmy Manyi, Nathi Mthethwa, Angie Motshekga, Gwede Mantashe, Ibrahim Patel, Blade Nzimande and even, sadly, Trevor Manuel (who everyone, myself included, thought was made of moral fibre and not the mobster mutton cloth his cadres find so fashionable). That these levels of ethical and moral pollution reside so comfortably with Kgalema Motlanthe and Jacob Zuma comes as no surprise.

Little wonder then that South Africa’s image has nosedived, both domestically and globally, to the depths of ranking the country 30th out of 34 least well run, and that its own citizenry are so pessimistic about it they rank it 32nd out 33 countries they’d like to be seen as.

No one whose eyes have been open for the past 15 years is in the least surprised the German soccer bosses have recommended their players wear “protective clothing” (bullet-proof vest) when away from their hotels during next year’s Soccer World Cup. What is surprising is the outrage with which this news has been greeted. If ever there was a sign of how inured, thick-skinned and arrogant we’ve become, that is it! It’s because our rulers have created such a bad impression across the world, have fostered criminality and vile entitlement at home, allowed justice to decay, wiped their feet on the Constitution, sung songs of love to automatic weapons, abused their positions of authority and respect and wasted billions of our tax rands, that a judge in Canada can quite readily believe the crap that Brandon Huntley argued. Have you ever attended a golf day organised by our embassy in Washington DC? No, probably not. Otherwise you would have been among the dozens of invited expat South Africans who left ashamed and embarrassed by the conduct and buffoonery of our own ambassadorial reps.

We who are genuinely concerned about where this magnificent country and its awesome people are being dragged by the lowlifes in power, share the feelings expressed below. We too are gatvol — have been for more years than we care to remember, have given and given and given for free to try to put right what has been made so wrong for so long, have preached positivism and cooperation and conciliation and upliftment and development and every other form of doing right and good. We too, white, black (and every shade between), old, young, ill, healthy, rich and (mostly) poor are GATVOL. And we share the setiments so poignantly, eloquently and damningly expressed below.

This is an excerpt from the latest newsletter of the South African Institute of Corporate Fraud Management, the country’s foremost private-sector body fighting corruption in business and industry in SA. Not only has this organisation been more successful in its field than any other group (or groups) of companies, but the SAICFM is recognised internationally as one of the most courageous and outspoken campaigners against corporate fraud. It is also the official research partner of the African Union, the New Partnership for African Development (Nepad) and the African Peer Review Mechanism (APRM).

The following was written last week, before the publication of the damning findings of the New York-based Reputation Institution on perceptions of SA, by the Institute’s president Bart Henderson, one of a handful of people in SA who can really be described as “brave”.

“Have a nice day. I simply cannot express the intensity with which I am clenching my teeth or the level of absolute aggravation and total frustration that I’m feeling.

“Firstly for some peculiar reason, post my last mail, I have found an increase in subscribers despite my stated intent to shut down on 31 December 2009 and requesting each and every one of you to click “Unsubscribe” at the bottom of this page.

“Those that don’t I stated I would migrate to my personal email database.

“For clarity purposes let me put this as bluntly as possible without losing composure or resorting to expletives.

“I am 100% completely, utterly, totally gatvol.

“I do not under any circumstances wish to engage on the subject of fraud, bribery and corruption in this country.

“I have spent 20 years in this business and travelled the world. There is not a single man, woman or child, in this country, that has PRODUCED more work than me in the field of either research or study or handled as many pro bono cases!

“I don’t have to listen to the horseshit being bandied about anymore, the never ending drivel that constitutes the never ending discourse on the subject of crime in this country.

“I am absolutely gatvol at the manner in which patently and blatantly vrot officials continue to enjoy the luxury of lying openly in my face and not even my face, sommer to the whole world with absolutely no shame!

“I am sick and tired of the waste, the greed, the arrogance and the self serving supercilious bullshit that is spewed on a daily basis.

“I am tired of the betrayal of our constitution, I am tired of the plunder of state resources, I am sick and tired of listening to people bitch about fraud and corruption and the state of government and society and this and that while they go home and sit at the tables of the very people who commit the acts against us!

“I am sick of watching the country disintegrate into a cesspool while people whinge about how THEY should be doing something about it and yet the masses do absolutely nothing.

“Who is they?

“Whose job is it anyway? While everyone is so busy worrying about the cellphone companies and their damned rates do you know that these same companies are responsible directly for people being murdered in their homes?

“Do you know that the cellphone companies are directly responsible for failing to provide the police with data that would allow the police to catch virtually every syndicate operating in this country?

“Not because the data is protected, personal information but because it’s inconvenient! Because as far as the cellphone companies are concerned if the police ask for the data in a specified format in the cellphone company’s opinion this constitutes a “fishing” expedition?

“That’s right; people are dying because the cellphone companies have decided it’s too inconvenient to produce data upon request?

“Not information about who owns a phone but simply where a particular phone with a particular signature might be at the time of a crime and after the crime was committed.

“That’s all!

“Do you people have any idea how frustrating it is to know this as a fact?

“And in the meantime I have this bureaucrat that is playing God and Russian roulette with people and police officers lives buying crap and selling it off as crime intelligence, software technology, hardware etc.etc.etc

“The SAPS have the technology to interrogate vast data stores but this mullet’s wife, his boss won’t plug it in?

“Speaking of which, where is the lease for the Crime Intelligence building? Who actually owns that building? When you answer these questions and find the culprit ask them to send a plumber and maintenance people. For a new building that one seems to have sprung more than a few leaks.

“Ja Director Willie Meyer, I’m talking to you!

“How much money have you spent over the years?

“How much more do you need and how much longer do you need?

“Your rubbish has held an entire force captive!

“How much of the inability of the SAPS to do their job stops with you?

“How many police officers have walked into ambushes or into a trap because you will not even look at alternative solutions that may, just may improve your crime intelligence capabilities?

“How many policemen must look into the faces of families torn by grief and not have an answer because the state of the SAPS IT, data, dockets, case management, profiles, intelligence, hell photocopiers never mind PC’s in every station after all these years is kak? And you and your ilk won’t answer a few questions but elect to send me lawyer’s letters to sue me?

“I can’t wait!

“I can’t wait because my friend if you want to test my theories in open court I am going to pull every tender, every crime stat, every dead cop incident, every murdered citizen I can find and do my damndest to drape your frame in shame!

“I hope in deepest sincerity that the Hawks do you!

“I will repeat this for you and Inkanyiso’s benefit that every Red Flag indicator of conflict of interest, lack of oversight and due diligence exists in the constitution and trade of that company.

“Anyone in Commercial Crime in the SAPS will recognise exactly what I do!

“All you had to do was answer the questions put to you by the journalist which you have still not done!

“Had you responded with a reasonable explanation there would have been no story?

“The fact that you didn’t, haven’t but instead chosen to threaten me tells me that you have something to answer to!

“You may be a cop but you wouldn’t know what being a cop is if it bit you on the arse. If you’re a crime fighter these criminals have klapped you bloedbek man.

“Sue me? You and Inkanyiso? Hell I’ve been close to totally broke with all the pro bono work and since another quagga came along called Manyatshe.

“Help yourself.

“Let me tell you how this is going to work, I publish every letter your lawyers send me and respond publicly to every letter you send me get the picture?

“Who the hell do you think you are?

“Answer the damn questions man!

“Then there is this bunch at Sita.

“You have a report that states categorically that there is R355-million in duplicate payments over a period of four years and you have said nothing about this single fact.

“You have 613 pages of exceptions providing you with a roadmap on what to fix and where to fix it and instead you bitch about process?

“That is all that has come out of that Board.

“You couldn’t care less that your incompetence has frustrated almost every Government Agency that has to deal with you?

“You couldn’t care less that you preside over an organisation that in the vast majority of decent hard working employees with the obvious exception of the varke that are getting their bit on the side have to go to work and live on a daily basis with the kak you spew out?

“They are the ones that have to deal with the customers, they are the ones who have to do the hard work and watch it unravel with your constant interference and meddling and complaining about what they’re doing wrong with just about everything that they do, do?

“You wonder where the skills are, you wonder where the institutional memory is, you wonder where the knowledge and experience is?

“Your reputation is in tatters and you scrounge around in the dirt trying to find every reason to deflect attention from your absolute incompetence and try lay blame on everyone else except yourselves?

“Read my lips, I quit.

“If Egshaan Khan believes he frustrated us by giving us the data in a format we couldn’t use he’s wrong.

“I don’t bluff.

“What you have done is make me work for months to do my job.

“My 36 gigabytes of your Head Office email communication tells me that you are the most useless bunch of shits feeding at a trough to sit on a board.

“That you are vindictive, that you are self serving, that you are arrogant and above all that you are plain incompetent!

“I am so tempted I have to fight to stop myself from publishing emails one mail at a time and would without second thought if it wasn’t for the fact that there are hundreds of employees, ordinary people who simply don’t deserve the rubbish you’re dishing up.

“I know exactly which suppliers you’ve screwed.

“I am more a patriot and citizen of this country than any single one of you fat cats!

“You are without exception traitors to the ideals of this country.

“Corruption, people, isn’t some abstract concept that gets discussed around a coffee table! It has a face, it has a nature, it has a pattern, it has a modus operandi as old as the bible and direct consequences.

“Manyatshe!

“Without me holding your hand that young turk Mampeule would have torn you to pieces.

“You sat there like a deer in headlamps without a clue what to do next.

“You know that, your wife knows that and the whole damned world knows that.

“What deals were you doing at MTN when you were forced to leave? I warned you in the beginning, don’t lie to me and don’t betray me.

“You have done both!

“What you and this bunch don’t get is that I don’t care what you do or don’t do.

“I care more about the people whose faces I look into every day by a long shot. So let the dice fall where they may.

“The day I shut up for the likes of you bunch hell will first freeze over!

“I’m sick of the likes of you and what you represent.

“Now if anyone reading this doesn’t like my tone or what I say or how I say it, this is a private forum, a rather large one granted… I pay for this damn service.”

WOW! Little wonder perceptions about this country are as bad as they are. Little wonder soccer players are advised to wear bullet-proof vests. Little wonder a Canadian judge and authority on immigration can readily believe the “evidence” of an irrigation salesman and grant him refugee status in that country. Little wonder 90% of people in three separate online polls recently overwhelmingly said they “do not trust the government under President Jacob Zuma”.

Money and power can — and do — usually buy most things. Not just in SA, but everywhere. Hence the adage about fooling some of the people some of the time, but … But you can’t buy your way out of these perception, Jacob, old chap. Not you nor any of your comrades. Aspirant woodworkers or failed spin doctors or whatever other party-throwers and hotel-goers and sycophants and rent-a-crowds applaud so avidly and so precisely on cue.




Related Posts

67 Responses to “Hey, Zuma, you can’t buy your way out of this one, old chap”

Who is the guy talking with that tone?
I absolutely love it!! It’s about time that we stop being so bureaucratic and politically correct and start calling things for what they are. That’s the only way we will move forward!

(Report abuse)

Sello on October 25th, 2009 at 8:58 pm

[…] Thought Leader » Llewellyn Kriel » Hey, Zuma, you can’t buy your way out of this one, old chap www.thoughtleader.co.za/llewellynkriel/2009/10/24/hey-zuma-you-cant-buy-your-way-out-of-this-one-old-chap – view page – cached Almost from the moment the rag-tag gaggle of erstwhile freedom fighters took over the reins of power — and, boy, did they love that power, like a kid who had just got his driver’s licence and was… (Read more)Almost from the moment the rag-tag gaggle of erstwhile freedom fighters took over the reins of power — and, boy, did they love that power, like a kid who had just got his driver’s licence and was put behind the wheel of a Ferrari — they realised that, even under someone of the statesmanship and stature of Nelson Mandela, they would be incapable of running South Africa without their hands being held all the way by the private sector. (Read less) — From the page […]

(Report abuse)


Mr Henderson

A braver man than most of us! I am glad I do not know the half of what has gotten you so worked up, but I feel it too.
Call me a coward, call me what they like, but I now live in a country with almost no litter, I have no fence around my proprerty, my car parks in the street, I very seldom lock a door, I have no gun under my pillow anymore, I gladly pay my taxes, and my children are happy and far, far safer than in RSA.

I am sorry I did not know you before, however, like most South Africans, I was just trying to work, survive and pay my taxes. Man that burnt my ass, knowing that my hard earned money was going to such uncaring, greedy, fat-cat despots, and that the millions that need it most, schools, hospitals, housing, etc, were never going to see it - not until elections that is.

The greed, the waste, the entitlement, the incompetence, the fraud & corruption, the blatant hatred & indifference, and the desperation leave me cold and angry at what could have been.

I have felt the angst, I have been on the receiving end of the hatred and intollerance and I am happy to be away from it.

Your letter sums up how so many feel - Good luck to you and those who are trying to do something!
Sadly I have to say - “I think it is all in vain”.

(Report abuse)

James Hatfield on October 26th, 2009 at 12:58 am

Thank you for your words Mr Kriel, I wonder how many readers like myself are thinking twice about commending you in this medium, with fraud and corruption being so rampant. This is affecting all of us in so many ways, our friends, families and our futures.

Remain steadfast and don’t let them get to you.
The true South African spirit will prevail.

(Report abuse)

Robert Branch on October 26th, 2009 at 1:06 am

As you said Llewllyn - WOW!
A brave man, Bart Henderson, and I hope we don’t see his name in the obituary column as a result.
It’s taken a long time, as I have always believed in this wonderful country, but I now officially resent paying taxes as a good citizen to fund the lying lifestyles of those who simply steal my hard-earned bucks.I’m working for the benefit of those who won’t, or who are simply pretending to.
Enough - and there are no making love to a machine gun songs (loved that Llewellyn - thanks!) which will make it what it just isn’t.

(Report abuse)

Sue on October 26th, 2009 at 5:40 am

WOW! Well said! Another WOW!

(Report abuse)

dj on October 26th, 2009 at 7:29 am

You are a brave man! Godspeed!

(Report abuse)

pong on October 26th, 2009 at 7:59 am

No comment except that I would really like to read all the stuff you have available, for I too am GATVOL.

(Report abuse)

Bodie on October 26th, 2009 at 9:06 am

EXCELLENT.
The 24/7 anger that millions of good SA’s feel…Well, Translate that into…thinking carefully where you place your vote ! Rid this country of this ANC government..that continues to rape,pillage and desecrat and then…LAUGH and LIE in your face, while they continue ,unabated to impoverish every single South African, by their vile deads !! Let them carry on doing it !!?? ….I dont F—ing think so !! Their time has come….!!

(Report abuse)

perplexed on October 26th, 2009 at 9:19 am

I think that the question on may peoples minds is, how do we organize ourselves to rid ourselves of this cancer?
We do hear a lot of talk on the forums, here and elsewhere, but the general sentiment seems to be that people don’t really know what to do about it.
How does one start up a grass roots movement invoke change?
How does one mobilize enough of the population to effect positive change?

(Report abuse)

Robin Grant on October 26th, 2009 at 10:06 am

“Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I’m not sure about the universe.”-Einstein

“Giving money and power to government is like giving whiskey and car keys to teenage boys.”
P. J. O’Rourke

(Report abuse)

Alice37 on October 26th, 2009 at 10:12 am

Brave man indeed - you have already been threatened, so I hope your family is safe and not in RSA.
Zuma has put forward Malema’s as a “President.” Does this non-leader President who allows “others” to determine policy -
know what he is doing ?
Encouraging SA YOUTH to stand up for their hero?
I say now -
Malema will be juggernauted to President at the next ANC President and thereby RSA president.
“Impossible” right thinking people will say !
I say not.
We have laughed at the presumed to be clown. Dismissed his “policies” which have ALL been carried out - Not so ?
Since the “I will kill for Zuma” I realised that this is an extremely dangerous, shrewd egomaniac and stated it on many blogs..
Malema is positioning himself NOW by “electioneering” at Varsities, trouble spots, dictating POLICY.
The media is all about Malema and his demands that come to fruition.
What more proof do you need ?
Will he and his uncontrolled hooligan following be patient and wait for power ?
Too young you say -
” Rajoelina, a 34-year-old former disc jockey who moved against the government after he was sacked as the capital’s mayor in February.”

Its reality except for those too blind to see and bury their heads in the sand.
SAZIM 2012 - a new Emperor !

(Report abuse)

old, female, paleface on October 26th, 2009 at 11:06 am

Most days I rant and rave as an armchair politician about the things mentioned here. And other days I am just quiet because the futility overwhelms me.

Im a single mom who’s daughter has to finish school and hopefully uni. Unfortunately at the ripe old age of 13 she already says “oh Mom whats the use”.

South Africa is all we know. If only I could “go back where I came from”, I would have left ages ago, for my daughter’s sake.

God help us. Malema is next choice for ANC president. Zuma reckons he is a leader in the making. Riiiiiiiight. Suppose if you are a dunce you would see potential in a bugger dunce. I shudder………..

(Report abuse)

Jax on October 26th, 2009 at 11:09 am

The amount of people slowly starting to speak out seems to be on the increase, only those whose interests lie with such a corrupt, incompetent, self indulgent party like the ANC would disagree.
At some stage there must be a tipping point going one way or another- personally I hope it tips in favour of the people where once again the government will realise that they are there to serve the people and not the other way round.
WHen was the last time anyone felt safe?

(Report abuse)

martyn Abrahams on October 26th, 2009 at 11:25 am

I think you have hit the nail on its head here. You undoubtedly speak for the minority. I just wish more people would speak up like you. SA needs and deserves it. in Namibia, I fear the same things happening and all one hears is TIA. I still hope that things will settle and we may produce an upstanding leader interested in its people rather than self, but if one goes into the history of Africa, its like wishing on for that Pot ‘o Gold at the end of the Rainbow. Good luck for the future, but for God’s sake don’t shut up, SA and Africa needs voices like yours.

(Report abuse)

SusiH on October 26th, 2009 at 12:15 pm

So true. And it’s a sad fact that one of the most popular pages among international visitors on a tourism website should be an attempt at a fair portrayal of crime in SA - http://capeinfo.com/crime-public-safety.

(Report abuse)

Carl on October 26th, 2009 at 12:36 pm

Awesome article! I was still optimistic about our country, even in the wake of the previous election.. hoping for the best despite the facts. It seems that every week more ridiculously selfish, huge-scale corruption is uncovered. And now not only do we get to see our tax money go to the fat cats, we also have to cough up way more for electricity & the inflation that these increases will bring. And why? So we can fund corruption & imbecilic mismanagement. I agree with you Robin Grant - I like the idea of a grass roots movement. It would be great to withhold taxes until such time as the numerous multi-million rand corruption findings have gone to trial and monies recouped. Would a first start not be getting a Facebook group going, building up a certain critical mass & then someone co-coordinating things once done?

(Report abuse)

gumrol on October 26th, 2009 at 12:47 pm

Well done Kriel and Hendersen.
To sum up everything that’s ailing SA it’s the lack of shame. While there was corruption under the Nats, and their racism was evil, at least they had a sense of shame (the corollary to decency).
The best the ANC can do is fulminate at Canada for accepting a white refugee or blasting the IAAF for following its own rules.

(Report abuse)

Theseus on October 26th, 2009 at 12:58 pm

All I can say is WOW. Start publishing what you have from abroad on these obese powermongering violence threatening education destroying things that run this country Mr Henderson. Problem is that all politicians are the same worldwide and will probably come to the defence of the things like themselves including the one who just one the Nobel prize after less than a year of what? Promising hope like all politicias do at election time.

(Report abuse)

GailC on October 26th, 2009 at 1:00 pm

One final thought: If there is an -ism in it DON’T TRUST it.

(Report abuse)

GailC on October 26th, 2009 at 1:03 pm

ANCYL has increased membership to over 1/2 mill. Malema is the pull factor.
Many thousands more youth at end of year are unemployable.
They will join ANCYL who will be a force to be feared.
MO is to make “ungovernable” if not obeyed. MKVA add to numbers.
Malema is a racist. Whites are scum and denigrated.
Warnings on 702 that after WC the “old privileged will pay ! ”
That is fact of life in SA.

Eskom need not look for trillions to expand - they can mothball - as capital flees.
Look to ZIM - the future RSA.

UDF was a mixed band of people who attacked Apartheid from within.
Black Sash women protested visibly. The face of national shame.
Are any pale faces and democratic black citizens ready to march and protest or to form a UNITED DEMOCRATIC FRONT ?

I doubt it - they will quietly depart to a stable, sane country away from our anarchy that will reign. Or vainly hope for the best.
At last - people are speaking up on forums. Up the tempo citizens!

(Report abuse)

old, female, paleface on October 26th, 2009 at 1:11 pm

Forgot this fact - government is to BORROW billions.
Why not print money ? Short term solution as in Zim.
That is where we are heading.

(Report abuse)

old, female, paleface on October 26th, 2009 at 1:14 pm

We now live in an indolent idiotocracy.

(Report abuse)

Martin on October 26th, 2009 at 1:31 pm

…and I thought I’d heard it all…now I realise I haven’t heard ‘the’ half of it!

I am gobsmacked, despite the fact that I already manage to find quite enough to get riled up about. This man needs to know that others are on his side and we all need to know that we are not alone. We also, I believe, need to know that others of all races get the point!

Do think that M&G should consider giving this chap a really well-paid regular column.

(Report abuse)

MLH on October 26th, 2009 at 1:39 pm

Well f-ing said!

(Report abuse)

Jagabags on October 26th, 2009 at 1:39 pm

If you want to do something that is constructive…Start by the simple things, first.

This is a M&G Column…where a hell of a lot of investigative journalism takes place.

Support this !!
How many of you..buy the Sunday Times..because it simply is, “the done thing”…”Think again!”
The M&G
Start by buying their news papers and increase their circulation and therefore encourage their investigative journalism…so more people..can be exposed to how are country is being looted by the ANC Government.
I have never done this before..but this is where I am going to start !!

(Report abuse)

perplexed on October 26th, 2009 at 3:59 pm

Johan Swarts on October 26th, 2009 at 5:08 pm

I’m not sure how many of my fellow south Africans see and understand the implications of what is going on right now…This is what should get people on the street…I am completely flabbergasted!…People we cannot allow this to carry on…the wealth (human and financial) is not bottomless…we are heading for a hellhole…what can we really do about it????

(Report abuse)

berry juice on October 26th, 2009 at 6:23 pm

While the masses will continue voting for the ANC (against their own best interests), any so=claaed grassroot opporition proposed above would eventually be labeled “counterrevolutionary” and the “enemy of the people”. Under a Malema administration, such acts will be deemed treason and will earn jsil terms. Mugabe provides a good example how to do it. Zim also has a Constitution, but what is it worth in practice? Even if MG can launch more intensive investigative journalism tgo unmaks the ANC fatcats, but who listens? Endemic corruption has been exposed before in many newspaper articles, but with no avail. No, one must simply wait until the entire edifice will collapse under its own weight, just like it happened in the Soviet Union (and for the same reasons).

(Report abuse)

ian shaw on October 26th, 2009 at 7:43 pm

To peddle your fear-based ideology, you’ve now replaced your flowery language with verbosity! LOL
Even if you have valid points, your desperate attempt to discredit the great strides made by our country since the fall of apartheid, drowns out your arguments.

Even the statistics that you quote are pulled out of some orifice, lacking any basis. How about using THIS statistic from http://www.heritage.org/Index/Ranking.aspx , which shows the “Link Between Economic Opportunity & Prosperity” which ranks South Africa (61) out of 179 countries ahead of countries like France (64), Italy (76), Poland (81), India (123)…..and might I remind you that the Heritage Foundation and the WSJ have extremely conservative views!

Your blog and its accompanying pathetic comments are similar to those of many apartheid apologists and denialists that serve only to ridicule the ANC at every turn in a mean-spirited way, is counter-productive and does a huge disservice to our country. Like the DA’s condescending demeanor to the ANC, it only serves to alienate others and further polarize our society. So its no surprise that we see a rise in militant forces in our democracy - in a strange way, it seems like we get exactly what we wish for!

(Report abuse)

Dave Harris on October 26th, 2009 at 9:37 pm

‘damning findings of the New York-based Reputation Institution’
Oh Llewellyn,if we’re going to insecurely rely on the findings of foreign based think-tanks to define ourselves as a country,why did you miss out this one,that Uh-Oh,ranks SA as the most properous country on the continent?
http://www.prnewswire.co.uk/cgi/news/release?id=269862
http://www.prosperity.com/rankings.aspx
But then again,that would’nt fit in with all your misery porn would it?

(Report abuse)

Zaza on October 26th, 2009 at 11:28 pm

is there a way of getting this guy on public platforms to say what he says, let him speak to the people because he knows what is talking about, how i wish he had a platform like a sound and morally defensible political party. if he were to talk to the masses everyone is feeling you brother, no one has ever spoken about corruption, fraud and all the way you just did, our people know there’s corruption but as defined by the opposition parties will not be seen or felt, you could be our saviour, talk to the media expose this malais let us defeat this monster eating our country, for fellow citizens contributing here, let us continue this struggle and assist our feloow counrty man not to fight this battle in Australia, Canada or UK because then he will lose the battle, I have cause to believe that the country has in some way found the answer to the political mediocrity and garbish. VIVA Bart Henderson VIVA

(Report abuse)

Tibla on October 27th, 2009 at 1:12 am

Time to ressurect the strategies of the Struggle…civil disobedience, strong community/grassroots organisations, mobilise local candidates for municipal/council elections, consumer boycott, etc.

Most Importantly - INFORMATION - people like Kriel and Henderson circulate their info/knowledge publicly. Use their media contacts to have stories published. Come on M&G!

(Report abuse)

Brad-in-Melbourne on October 27th, 2009 at 3:18 am

Can’t be a proper kakistocracy without plenty of the key ingredient…

(Report abuse)

Blip on October 27th, 2009 at 5:44 am

I think its about time we sorted these fat cats out! Lovely article.

(Report abuse)

Paul A on October 27th, 2009 at 9:31 am

What a sad indictment of the society we have been forced to become ! The indolence of the ruling party have slowly sucked dry the last vestiges of moral decency and integrity this fine Country has built up over the years. The brazen way in which the justice system has been subverted - and our acceptance therof, we have been browbeaten so continuously, we sit back and accept it ! Is Willie Meyer not guilty of the worst possible form of treason ? And what of the billions of taxpayer money which is slowly (inexorably) slipping into their pockets - they steal, as we know and we are powerless.
Is it not possible for someone (probably white )to start a movement to tear open these festering financial sores, and fight it in open court, exposing the evidence you have, where even our crooked courts can’t hide from public opinion, we could donate funds to fight this tyranny.
I know “we had our turn at the trough ” but I’m just as sure that its not only whites who have issues with the trough dwellers !!
We can’t just talk about it - you seem pissed off enough to take up the fight - come on …..test the waters (what have we got to lose ??”)

(Report abuse)

Esjayoh on October 27th, 2009 at 10:08 am

Where are the black commentators?

(Report abuse)

Mike on October 27th, 2009 at 10:15 am

berry juice -
None so blind as those who will not see.
I am overjoyed that - AT LONG LAST - I am no longer one of the few doom sayers.
Citizens are taking note and becoming concerned.
Local elections next year - start to TALK POLITICS people. Most of us avoid the subject as “too depressing.”
Dear Lord - if everyone had said that from 1980’s we would not have an ANC today.
I regret cursing the Nats those days as I got what I voted for.

We need a strong opposition and that comes from the voting booth.
Canvass your friends, be a nuisance, nag, cajole, scare the hell out of everyone as I have been doing for the past 2 years.
Help me !

(Report abuse)

old, female, paleface on October 27th, 2009 at 10:31 am

It’s quite easy for people who are not in the RSA to shout to the rooftops about how bad it is in the RSA. However I don’t know whether it’ll do any good, it’s not like the protests outside South Africa House in London in the Apartheid Era which were seen by many people.

(Report abuse)

Stewie on October 27th, 2009 at 11:56 am

@zaza — Yes, South Africa is the most properous country on the African continent. That says more about the rest of Africa than it says about South Africa. Yes — we are more prosperous than Zimbabwe, Mozambique, Somalia….well, everybody, really. That does not mean that something is not rotten in the state of Denmark.

Yes, we are prosperous. And corrupt.

(Report abuse)

Piet Opperman on October 27th, 2009 at 12:22 pm

Okay, I’m a black comentator. Grew up with the ANC (not a staunch participant though), voted for them in 1994 when I was a student. Criticized the DA under Tony Leon, then with the skirmishes in ruling party leading up to Polokwane, and afterwards - I SAW THE LIGHT. Absolute Power corrupts - we cannot give too much power political gang. Then I decided then that I should not follow parties - rather I should vote to strengthen opposition, even if the party I vote for now becomes too powerful - I shall change my vote to another party in order to strngthen opposition.
But this sort of mentality needs to be taught to the masses. Some people are slow in catching up, hell - a Zim friend of mine keeps saying to me: it took the MDC over 10 yrs to get at least 50% of the Zim electorate to vote against the Zanu-PF (which was also a Liberation Movement). And they did that by saying the same thing consistently: “We acknowledge Zanu-PF for freeing us, but we believe they are no longer serving the interests of the public but their own, and we can help change that if you vote for us.” More than 10 yrs of the same message!!!
It will not be easy… it requires strong leadership skills, perseverence, etc. Even the ANC itself desparately needs a stronger leader now more than before, someone who is not afraid to discipline his comrades when they go astray.

(Report abuse)

Kay on October 27th, 2009 at 12:30 pm

South Africans must remember that Zimbabwe progressed economically for a while until the leadership learned how corruption could feather their personal nests. The more they learned, the more corrupt they became and now Zim is in a fix because the corrupt want to hold on to their corrupt practices. South Africans must at least try and kill corruption whenever they see it, and only a free press can make this happen. But I have my doubts that South Africa can hold back the tidal wave of corruption that seems to be sweeping the land. You can only try. To not try is to fail for sure.

(Report abuse)

Dave (Zim) on October 27th, 2009 at 1:12 pm

Does anyone really believe that should the ANC be fairly beaten in a general election, they will hand over power, peacefully? I daresay, never. The closest thing they will opt for, is possibly, a government of power-sharing. Barring this, they will incite their youth brigade to burn the country to the ground. Wake up and smell the coffee. The die has been cast.

(Report abuse)

Prophet of doom on October 27th, 2009 at 1:28 pm

Prophet of doom - thank you for saying these words.
Mine have become heavily moderated and censored and I am banned on most.
I try now - to be correct.

I keep referring to SAZIM and look North. That is the blueprint for ANC.
Remember youth vets ?
Racism as a war cry ?
It is here in the present and moving inexorably forward to next mover after WC 2010.
A SAPS vehicle stopped a car - a white woman in Gauteng, was dragged from the car away from her husband by COPS in uniform and raped continuously, assaulted and dumped at a College.
The COPS at Kempton Park would not take details of assault.
The husband was taken to the station on a trumped up charge.
It is in Beeld - not the English media.
WHY - It is a “racist white” so not worth the space !

This is a sign of the times.

(Report abuse)

old, female, paleface on October 27th, 2009 at 2:33 pm

http://www.news24.com/Content/SouthAfrica/News/1059/722052ef91364781b2ba6c5285679
A mother-of-three was allegedly “repeatedly” raped by two uniformed policemen in Kempton Park in the early hours of Sunday morning.
When he heard about it, Martie Olivier’s husband, Sarel, went to the Kempton Park police station and assaulted various police officers on duty before being brought under control.
He said they were unable to lay a charge of rape later that day because the police refused to take their statements.
She was, however, medically examined and the couple’s vehicle was also searched. Charges of rape, assault and bribery were finally laid on Monday morning and the couple’s statements were taken.
“The case is now being investigated,” said Opperman.
Police spokesperson Senior Superintendent Vish Naidoo added that charges of this nature were regarded in a very serious light.

You need to read the whole article to see the brutality and humiliation by those who serve to protect.

RACIST attack or not ?

(Report abuse)

old, female, paleface on October 27th, 2009 at 2:53 pm

I am also GATVOL and will join any organisation to try and rectify what is destroying our country.

(Report abuse)

Andre Pretorius on October 27th, 2009 at 3:03 pm

‘Mike’ ‘Where are the black commentators?’
What a bizarre thing to say,how can you tell who is black or white hmm?

And why does it matter to you?
Stop obsessing about race.

(Report abuse)

Zaza on October 27th, 2009 at 5:14 pm

Bart Henderson is indeed acting very bravely. How might we support him? And bravo Llewelyn for your article.

Bring back the honest and potent UDF. But all that would happen is a concerted government attack on the W. Cape.

So the best and the ONLY way to hit these Mafuta Pigs where it hurts most is a TAX BOYCOTT by all conscious and concerned tax payers in SA. Woza the Great Tax Boycott of 2010/2011, woza!

Amandla! Awethu!

(Report abuse)

Citizen Mntu on October 27th, 2009 at 5:24 pm

Dave Harris. Forget the statistics man. Look at the facts.
Corruption is rife and the country is going to the dogs.
Stop defending these crooked buddies of yours, we all know that you are nothing more than an ANC stooge.

(Report abuse)

Joe on October 27th, 2009 at 9:45 pm

Reputation Institution is a joke - more of a political lobby with questionable methodologies that sells their “research” to the highest corporate bidder! How about another recent report from a real worldwide authority like World Economic Forum, which makes us proud to be South African:
http://www.weforum.org/en/Communities/Women%20Leaders%20and%20Gender%20Parity/GenderGapNetwork/index.htm
South Africa and Lesotho - have leapt into the top 10 ranking of countries where women face the least discrimination. SA sprang from 22 to 6 -thanks to the consistent efforts of the ANC to include women in all spheres of government and the implementation of AA, women can once again progress in our society. This is in stark contrast to the disgraceful appointment of an ALL-MALE cabinet in the Cape by our NP-Lite party, the DA, still stuck in apartheid era politics.

Don’t you think its time to quit pushing your “misery porn” eh?

(Report abuse)

Dave Harris on October 28th, 2009 at 7:16 am

I ask you Dave Harris, why with the overwhelming evidence that the ANC is not performing do you continue to support them. You veil your comments with your rhetoric of “white domination” and “apartheid apologists” but this serves to divert from the real issues at hand.

The reason for the “mean spirited” and “counter productive” criticism is that this government and supporters in no way support or even understand the concept of democracy, freedom of speech political debate. Although you do it on a slightly higher level than the Malema’s in government, you attempt to shut down debate by whipping out the race card.

I am one of those semi-privileged white boys so the governments mismanagement doesn’t effect me too much. My concern is for the CURRENTLY disadvantaged. Colonialism, migrant labour, bantustans and apartheid have all economically disenfranchised the majority of the population.

As Eddie Murphy would say “what have you done for me lately?” How does cadre deployment of incapable and unsuitable people help those in the poorer municipalities?
Why does the government hold onto apartheid era rules that allow for 1 million rand cars?
Why are the tender processes so corrupt?
The past can be used to explain many things but not these.
I acknowledge that the ANC has made some progress but until they allow constructive debate there will be severe criticism.

(Report abuse)

Chris E on October 28th, 2009 at 9:55 am

Oh, Dave Harris, you are absolutely correct, and nowhere is the ANC’s enlightened attitude to women more obvious than in our beloved President with his six wives (is it six? I lose track of the numbers sometimes!)

The strategy has to be admired: always have a goodly number of women around from which to choose your next wife. The bouquet from the WEF is just a bonus.

And Dave, just a gentle correction: I am proud to be a South African. I am just not prod of the corruption that is endemic to our government and society.

(Report abuse)

Piet Opperman on October 28th, 2009 at 12:35 pm

@Chris E
“…why…. ANC is not performing do you continue to support them. ”
I have always maintained that absolute power corrupts absolutely and not in favor of a one-party state. The utter failure of the racist DA party in becoming a credible opposition and COPE still getting of the ground, renders us a one-party state. The core of the ANC however, is still the party of liberation with extraordinarily dedicated individuals. The unavoidable corruption resulting from a one-party system needs to be addressed by both:
1. Encouraging the dominant party to put in structures to enable checks and balances in the interests of its own long term viability
2. Building a strong opposition party that can stand up to the ANC.

My “rhetoric” when I refer to “white supremacy” and “apartheid apologists” are FACTS. Many SA whites have BLINDSPOTS to their racism and have developed amnesia to the CENTURIES of white supremacy. Not surprisingly white SAns have the greatest difficulty adapting to life overseas when they emigrate?

“you attempt to shut down debate by whipping out the race card.”
So why won’t you acknowledge and compensate for past injustices? You cannot have your cake and eat it!!!

“..but until they (ANC) allow constructive debate there will be severe criticism”
Did you send a thank-you letter to the ANC for giving us a first free press? I haven’t head of ANYONE being banned, jailed by the ANC for engaging in constructive criticism?

(Report abuse)

Dave Harris on October 28th, 2009 at 6:55 pm

@Dave Harris

Sorry, Dave, you are entitled to your own opinions, but you are not entitled to your own facts.

Words like “many”, “centuries” and “BLINDSPOTS” are indicative of opinion, and biased opinion at that.

Dave there is a word for the practice of extrapolating your own (limited) experience to an entire population based on skin colour, race, sex, religion or whatever. I expect you know what that word is.

As for your unsubstantiated assertion that “white” South Africans do not adjust well when they emigrate — sorry, my friend. That is actually diametrically incorrect. There is some empirical and a large body of anecdotal evidence to say that they adapt exceedingly well, better than most. That makes sense — it is surprisingly easy to adapt to a life that is relatively free of crime, corruption, and insults based on your skin colour and the sins of your fathers.

(Report abuse)

Piet Opperman on October 29th, 2009 at 11:46 am

Dave Harris - I was under the impression that you no longer live in South Africa; am I misinformed?

(Report abuse)

Dawn on October 29th, 2009 at 1:06 pm

As a foreign national now living in SA, it makes me so sad that no one actually does anything about the corruption here. I echo the words of Llewllyn, he conveys exactly how I feel living in this shameful democracy. Black people are in power and they have only abused this. Where is the R600m from Rasoul’s era that was meant to go our sector - the NGOs, the very people committed to REALLY helping South Africa. Malema in power will result in SA being the laughing stock of the world. When I go home to Europe, people can’t believe there is such a twit in power right now. I can only keep positive. Where to from now? The intelligence is in the minority in this country, I’d love to stand against what’s happening to this country at the hands of the ANC. Are there any organisations / petitions?

(Report abuse)

Claire on October 29th, 2009 at 3:46 pm

@Dawn
Whatever gave you that impression ;-)
btw. Would you like to know my race, age, and sexual preference as well?

@Piet Opperman
Was I speaking to you or Chris E in my last comment?

(Report abuse)

Dave Harris on October 29th, 2009 at 4:10 pm

@Dave Harris

If you want to speak to Chris E privately, I suggest that the two of you get a room.

(Report abuse)

Piet Opperman on October 29th, 2009 at 4:32 pm

Dave Harris for Emperor of the Milky Way. The guy is just awesome for blog ratings. Thanks Dave - I love you comrade ubergruppenfuhrer gauleiter lord grand inquisitor commissar hero of the people and paramount chief. You rock man (or I think it’s “man”).

(Report abuse)

Llewellyn Kriel on October 29th, 2009 at 4:51 pm

Thank you. For the record I am neither brave nor stupid. I am not a racist because truthfully I actually don’t with absolute certainty know what I am (racially speaking) and hypocrisy isn’t my strongest suit.

Having said this some perspective on perceptions expressed here is required. For the record a great deal of the current malaise was engineered under Mbeki. It’s President Zuma by the way, deserves a chance. The ANC is in power.

Deal with it.

When I wrote that article I aimed it at whites.

There are as many white (per capita) sponsoring fraud and corruption as there are blacks giving or taking. This is NOT A RACE ISSUE! It is AN ISSUE that is tearing at the very fabric of an entire society! Where are my people?

Black and white that made me so proud?

For those of you that have expressed such warm uncluttered support… I am absolutely stunned and deeply humbled. Thank you.

(Report abuse)

Bart Henderson on October 29th, 2009 at 7:00 pm

oh my bad for not replying. Piet sort of said what I had in mind.

Dave i actually agree with some of what you say and I can see where you are coming from but I still have a problem with how you do it.

“White” South Africans are not a hegemonic group. Firstly there is a language divide and an age divide.
I agree there are lots of “white” racists out there but you cannot paint every critic with that brush as it detracts from discussing the issues.

I agree with Bart’s comments too.
I am actually semi-hopeful about the Zuma government they have taken some good steps in the right direction and this is not an issue of race.

It is just some people within the government who display actions that mirror other post-colonial states. (Yes i know SA is not STRICTLY post-colonial but it damn near close enough).
It’s the extravagant spending, the highly racial and violent discourse spouted by some. (Mostly youth but also by some ANC and ANC affiliates).
It is also the biblical and god-like references attributed to leaders. (ANC will rule until Jesus returns and the JZ/Jesus comparison).
Oh and the corruption.

I’m not a racist white person and it is irksome to deal with friends and others who are. So when you start to talk about the racist previously imperial white people it detracts from discussion and it alienates all non-racist white people.

(Report abuse)

Chris E on October 30th, 2009 at 7:54 pm

@ Llewellyn.

? Thank you for your contribution to lifting flagging spirits. What a welcome and generous surprise.

Warm regards

Bart

(Report abuse)

Bart Henderson on October 31st, 2009 at 1:06 pm

Re the race and corruption issue, if you leave the hen-house open the foxes of all colours and nationalities will be there in a feeding frenzy.

(Report abuse)

r mayer on November 1st, 2009 at 8:44 am

Give praise where praise is due, Bart. With no heroes, leaders or morality in the ANC and strukshas, those rare individuals with morality, integrity and courage have earned to right to support. Keep shining - without the likes of you SA is lost.
BTW this blog has been picked up Der Spiegel, NYT and Washington Post, so we’re obviously doing something right.

(Report abuse)

Llewellyn Kriel on November 1st, 2009 at 9:54 am

@Chris E
“..but you cannot paint every critic with that brush…”
Its not every critic but SOME critics like Llewellyn Kriel need to be exposed in the harsh sunlight - just read his previous mean-spirited blogs. Just like apartheid, the nature of his blogs seeks to divide, demean and destroy rather than unify, uplift and create a new SA.
On the other hand, Breyten Breytenbach is one of South Africa’s true patriotic sons. As a poet and anti-apartheid activist he even has the courage to criticize Mandela in his his essay “Mandela’s Smile” http://www.thetruthseeker.co.uk/article.asp?ID=9848 where he tries to focus attention to the abnormal nature of violent crime in our country.

“…when you start to talk about the racist previously imperial white people it detracts…”
ALL SA whites are direct beneficiaries of centuries of white supremacy and imperialism - this is an INDISPUTABLE FACT yet the majority of whites vehemently oppose AA and deny voting for the Nats - How can whites and blacks move forward as a nation with such blatant hypocrisy?

(Report abuse)

Dave Harris on November 2nd, 2009 at 3:20 pm

@ Dave Harris “All white South Africans are beneficiaries…?” Really? Does that include the 10-year old boy, born of uneducated and dirt-poor parents (just as one example).

You are a racist, Dave Harris. You generalise, and you stereotype based on the colour of people’s skin.

As I said before, you are entitled to your own opinions, but not to your own facts. Calling your facts “indisputable” and capitalising them does not make them real facts. It just makes you look like an emotional bully, which I am sure you are not.

(Report abuse)

Piet Opperman on November 2nd, 2009 at 6:02 pm

@Kay “I SAW THE LIGHT. Absolute Power corrupts”
Sorry to correct you - but the correct saying is: “Power corrupts - ABSOLUTE power corrupts absolutely”

@Llewellyn Kriel - and in Australia and New Zealand as well.

@Old, Female - sorry but the link are no longer valid - any newer ones?

(Report abuse)

jay on February 17th, 2010 at 5:03 am

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

We have put a word limit of 250 words on all your comments


words left

Llewellyn's links


Addiction Action Campaign
My blogsite as Editor at the AAC
more posts
Maybe rising to the challenge would be a good start. Sociologists agree that few facets of the human experience so effectively transcend divisions to ...
Most of us ordinary, reasonably decent people have difficulty wrapping our minds around the legal notion of a company being a "person" in the same way...
When he was only 12, William Ernest Henley contracted tuberculosis of the bone. Eventually his left foot had to be amputated just below the knee. He s...
There is a temptation to see South Africa as a self-cannibalising charity case. Given the vast number of charitable causes, NGOs, NPOs and beggars on ...
I have taken enormous liberties with this blog. Liberties which I trust the original poet, a legend in his own lifetime and an enduring icon in my...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 102639
Total comments 1574
Llewellyn's tags
advertisement
    Mail & Guardian Online Headlines
  • National
  • Business
  • Africa
  • World
  • Sport
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator