We were the country that fought against all odds, that stood up to perpetrators of human rights though it meant lives and futures were lost. We were the freedom fighters, the reconcilers, and set ourselves as an example for revolutionaries the world over. But fifteen years after our democracy was born, we are a split nation beyond income, education and opportunity. Revolution now belongs to the poor, while the middle class has claimed apathy as its way of life.
I was angered for a long time because of the indifference, the conscious ignorance that has gripped the people who I meet daily, and who live, drive and float in the same economic and class circles. It was a long and arduous process trying to figure out where this misplaced apathy came from, but finally I’ve got it: South Africans are merely confused. For many years, our governments’ words and actions have been contradictory to the point of absurdity, and it seems to have left civilians in a state of bewilderment. Do we support the US wars in Iraq and Afghanistan or not? Are we okay with the Israeli occupation or are they violating human rights? Do we support justice for tyrants or ignore their warrants? It’s not that South Africans don’t care, it’s that they’re just not sure. All thanks to government policies which put their money, no strike that, our money, everywhere but where their mouth is.
What seems like ages ago, as the US prepared to enter Iraq, our president at the time, Thabo Mbeki, accused Britain and the US of international bullying and warned that “the prospect facing the people of Iraq should serve as sufficient warning that in future we too might have others descend on us, guns in hand”. Mugabe issues aside, I was proud of Mbeki that day.
Then, two months ago, in another show of potential revolt against the colonisers, we watched as Jacob Zuma did nothing while the African Union chose to ignore the warrant for the arrest of Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir for war crimes. Because they’re standing up for the little people. Because they don’t see why Africans should be prosecuted and not the Bush administration. Because two wrongs, apparently, make a right.
Both these presidents intended to act with a nobility that showed that we will not be walked over by the rich and powerful West. But I don’t believe them. Both these presidents have been in charge, all powerful and all seeing while South Africa has been exporting arms, the same guns which Mbeki warned us about, to the United States to use against civilians in Iraq and Afghanistan. Last year the government had to pay up R660 million in taxpayers’ money to bail out struggling state-owned arms manufacturer Denel so that it could continue supplying weapons to maintain the above-mentioned wars. In March this year, Denel Aviation was named an official maintenance and repair service centre for Lockheed Martin’s C-130 and L-100 aircraft, used in the same wars. A short while ago, Gilbert do Nascimento, executive of marketing and sales at Denel, boasted about the company’s full order books, including a deal to supply 50 hand-held surveillance units to the US armed forces in Afghanistan.
It is no secret that the US sends approximately $7 million a day to Israel in funds and military equipment. The guns that occupy and the tanks that steamroll the land which has so often been said to resemble South Africa’s dark past, by outsiders and insiders alike, are very likely to come from our own soil. And all the while, our Human Sciences Research Council releases a report, only a month ago, funded by the department of foreign affairs, which finds that while “both colonialism and apartheid are prohibited by international law … Israel has violated, and continues to violate, both prohibitions in the occupied Palestinian territories”.
Though Cosatu members refuse to offload a container ship with Israeli goods, our government sees no problem in the continued existence of the Israeli embassy in Pretoria, and the maintenance of a South African ambassador in Tel Aviv. Five years after Zuma said at the memorial service for the late Palestinian president Yasser Arafat that “we are … recommitting and rededicating ourselves to the cause he fought for, the freedom and self-determination of the Palestinian people” a July report by the Grassroots Palestinian Anti-apartheid Wall Campaign found that state-owned companies are still dealing not only with Israeli businesses but with ones directly linked to the occupation.
Although South Africa submitted a written statement to the International Court of Justice in 2004 expressing its consideration of both the apartheid wall and settlements illegal by international law, Eskom has been working locally with the Israel Electric Company, a 99% state-owned firm that has been actively helping to build new settlements and connect them to the power grid. Telkom has tried to outsource information technology processes to Amdocs, an Israeli firm suspected of using billing records as a means of intelligence gathering, but was stopped by unions who got wind of the matter. Transnet has previously contracted Israeli firms NICE and Orsus, who develop surveillance technology, much of which has been used against and tested on occupied Palestinians.
When Democratic Alliance MP David Maynier exposes the country’s dodgy arms dealings, he gets into trouble. He is not applauded for bringing to light information the public should have known, but is chastised for doing it illegitimately.
So what do we believe — actions certainly do speak louder than words, in a manner of speaking. But perhaps there is hope: Lindiwe Sisulu has called for Denel to be strategically “realigned”. Although this is the same woman who, as minister of housing, forcefully removed thousands of residents from Joe Slovo informal settlement in Cape Town two years ago, to make room for unaffordable accommodation along the N2, to look pretty for the tourists. She too, confused the public by explaining how those removed would be moving from their shacks to houses in Delft. She forgot to mention the problem of squatters in the houses and the fact that the new tenants would never be able to afford the transport costs that come with being forcefully removed to an area in the middle of nowhere. So when South Africans saw these new home owners angry and protesting, they were simply befuddled.
And a month ago, while the poor were desperately calling for service delivery they have so often been promised, our president, Zuma, pleaded with them to give him more time. This while his new communications minister was splashing out R1 million each on two luxury vehicles as part of his “prescribed guidelines”. I am baffled. So are the men and women in Diepsloot and Tokoza. More so are the people of Houghton and Camps Bay. Perhaps it’s the idealist in me, but I always hoped that if those people weren’t confused, if they knew what was really going on, none of this would be happening. Someone needs to clear this all up.
This entry was posted
on Wednesday, September 2nd, 2009 at 6:59 pm and is filed under Perspective.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
13 Responses to “South Africans are not apathetic, just confused”
David Maynier did not expose arms deals to Israel and to America, which I would assume since you know about them, were above board and fine, he exposed arms deals to Zimbabwe, Syria, Iran, and other fine examples of dictatorships, theocracies, and oppressive regimes that subjugate their people, and are very likely to use the weapons against their own people, rather than the governments that you mentioned that are controlled by their civilians.
More important than whether or not support is given to Israel, a democracy, in which all its citizens have access to the same rights, in electricity development, our votes against the rights of homosexuals in the UN, and votes against more action over Burma and other fine examples of votes supporting again dictators, theocracies, and oppressive regimes that subjugate their own civilian’s human rights, freedoms, and structures.
I do not not know what SUBJECT you are addressing. Israel, Sisulu, Housing, Denel, apathetic public, of Government not keeping its promises. ? ?
I am not confused in that -
we are heading to a “failed State” a direct fast path - without deviation.
YES! Citizens shut up as they are “shouted down” being called Racist, Colonialists and whatever on any point of reason.
These non-African, unwanted voters, have the means to leave as their skills are needed overseas and discarded here.
The rest of the pure Africans ?
They get the government they slavishly vote for decade after decade. Promises are all that it takes !
I do not call that “confused” do you ?
1. Lockheed Martin’s C-130 and L-100 aircraft are probably more frequently used in peace keeping operations than in war zones, example world food program. 2. There never was a nation of palistinians in the history of the world, they`ve only existed since Israel came into being, they are refugees because there own people (Egypt, Jordan, Syria, Lebabnon)turned their backs on them for political/religious reasons after the war, they should be integrated back into the above mentioned countries, not demand a piece of Israel.
3. Leave Israel alone
4.Terrorism is a fact that cannot be denied, do you suggest Denel manuf water guns to fight them with?
4. Zimabawe - breadbasket to basketcase and we are on the same path, only difference is i`m white and qualified, I can go overseas when the sh1T hits the fan, what about the (very) poor blacks that will be left behind (They are going to be needing those C130/L100 aircraft urgently and in more numbers than ever before). The ANC (not all individuals) is killing the goose that lays the golden egg.
I sometimes wonder about these ‘gurus’ who sit quietly in corners by themselves and dream about utopia and then insist that SOUTH AFRICA has not lived up to their image of this world. These are the very people who did not lift a finger to bring about the revolution in this country. These are the ones who benefitted to a large degree and these are the ones who act as some’Dalai Lama’who seemingly have all the expertise and knowledge. In their world, there are no contradictions and restrictions. Now, I wonder if these gurus are active amongst the poor.Do they help when there are floods,do they make a pot of soup to feed the poor,do they sit with the sick in shacks and give them medicine? Did they engage with those who do and tell them how to be better at what they do? In fact,what are these gurus timelines,or their programme of action?Let us remind ourselves: NO-ONE prepared ANYONE for ALL THE WORK that needed to be done to transform this country. There was NO SA handbook.Their is NO MANUAL! The contradictions is part of the process.Look at Cuba,it took them 40yrs to produce the best doctors in the world. The unrealistic expectations created by our new elite is SIMPLY disingenuous.They sit in glass-houses, throw stones and offend all of those who do a great job under extreme conditions. How convenient!
No wonder South Africans are confused. Even their government ministers are confused. Two cars for one person?? Two cars costing more than a million bucks EACH for one miserable gravy trainer?? Why TWO??
It would cost around R700 to R1000 to schlep the car by car carrying trucks from Pretoria to Cape Town for each parliamentary session.
Then to keep us confused, we MUST have 2 houses of parliament. Why can’t we keep just one, with all the stuff in it. We can turn the other one into an hotel with casino and fill it with tourists for 2010. It will be less of a circus, but will also cost us confused fellows less taxes too.
I disagree with you totally. South Africans are not and are never confused. South Africans are brilliant bunch of people.
Kam on, talk of hidden charges, your headline is; you’ve been going on and on about Middle East politics line after line.
Please: Denel is a big SA foreign income earner and a very bigger employment partner in the country. talk of recession, SA needs this scarce foreign money. By the way, SA is the only and outstandingly the best in Africa in aviation, madam Rawoot.
Its like abolishing export of Coffee in Kenya to the UK, because britons are in war with Ireland!!
Complaining is the first part, we should now mobilize and make our voices heard by giving mandate to a government that has a clue about what is happening. We realise the carnage awaiting us in a few years time, let’s do something about it! Sadly, the electorate does not understand the concept of a government and so change is years away and confusion, befuddlement will be our friend for as many years.
Thank you Ilham for saying what needs to be said. From some of the responses to your blog I’d say some South Africans are biased, not just confused. Keep up the good work.
counter-revolutionary, third world child on September 7th, 2009 at 12:27 pm
Quite unlike many of the commentaries here I do not find your post a meandering nor confusing. Not sure if South Africans are indeed confused though. Demobolised perhaps? Fearless post, this is. Pay no notice to Martyres. His/her measuring-line is hopelessly inadequate, rendering his/her commentary in the context of your post manifestly unsound and rather absurd. Sleep sound at night Ms Rawoot, some people won’t see even if the light of truth blazes them. Tsk! Silly, lazy buggers!
All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.
profile
I'm a journalist, I like persimmons, I'm good with directions, and people think I'm short but it's actually an optical illusion.
I'm one of those people who know which side of the fence they're on on pretty much every topic they've come into contact with. So now that I am confli...
I have been deflowered. The days of wondering what it's like and when my time will come, if I'm ready and whether I'll be disappointed, are long gone....
If you've been following my recent moans on the lack of party! party! in Grahamstown, you will be happy to know that I am far more satiated today than...
After three nights and almost three days at the festival, the cosy crimson-lit evenings that trail into the early hours around golden goblets and feas...
The National Arts Festival has kicked off. More like, started a brisk walk. I managed to see through my first day in the town I almost studied in. I a...
David Maynier did not expose arms deals to Israel and to America, which I would assume since you know about them, were above board and fine, he exposed arms deals to Zimbabwe, Syria, Iran, and other fine examples of dictatorships, theocracies, and oppressive regimes that subjugate their people, and are very likely to use the weapons against their own people, rather than the governments that you mentioned that are controlled by their civilians.
More important than whether or not support is given to Israel, a democracy, in which all its citizens have access to the same rights, in electricity development, our votes against the rights of homosexuals in the UN, and votes against more action over Burma and other fine examples of votes supporting again dictators, theocracies, and oppressive regimes that subjugate their own civilian’s human rights, freedoms, and structures.
(Report abuse)