« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

No one thought any worse of Californians when that US state plunged into a power crisis a few years back. Yet we South Africans are upset about both our current (or lack thereof!) situation and its effect on our image.

The sentiment is that we’ve now been shown up as no different to the “rest of Africa”; that we’re shedding our international image faster than Eskom seeks to shed its umzima.

Likewise, our 2010 victory now portends further embarrassment. What alternative after-hours recreation can we offer the soccer tourists — perhaps lure them into a bit of star-gazing at the Karoo’s Sutherland?

Reinforcing Eskom’s jolt to our national joy and dignity is the Selebi saga.

We originally celebrated a compatriot who could ride on our national reputation to secure the collective prestige of heading up Interpol. Now he’s accused of disgracing us — and compounding it even more, our president allowed him to linger in office despite all the concerns.

Also depressing is the signal emitted by an ANC president facing fraud charges, and one-third of the ANC’s new executive members reported with ethical or legal lapses to their names.

Another setback for our morale is Kenya, when we’ve only just survived “contamination” from Zimbabwe. That East African country is being read as an adverse symbol for the continent more broadly.

The Financial Times newspaper earlier this month wrote of the Kenyan crisis: “Africans still tend to vote for who they are rather than what they believe in.” The journalist penning this grossly sweeping statement also hearkened back to Rwanda, and warned of the dangers of “politics that draw on identity rather than ideology”.

Our national malaise is because of these kinds of generalisations that imply that Africans are backward and incapable of rationality. We’re unhappy to see so much potential ammunition being given to people who want “proof” of their prejudice.

For the record, and contra the FT, despite the real ethnic tensions in post-election Kenya, much of the initial voting was along class rather than tribal lines. In South Africa, the ANC internal elections weren’t ethnic.

On the other hand, many of the First World’s own backyards have more than enough identity politics, which is why Obama won in South Carolina, and why the European Union still hasn’t been able push ahead with constitutional amendments.

Also, many places besides South Africa show poor judgement about balancing markets with state control. California messed up its electricity supply by insufficient regulation of companies; Thabo misguidedly put his faith in a monopoly state enterprise (part of the “development state”?).

Even regarding the home-loan credit crisis abroad, bad governance decisions can be blamed. But lucky for Americans and Brits, we don’t generalise about them as a people.

Nevertheless, to a favourite term from Nelson Mandela, our recent events are affecting our global image, like it or not. So there’s good reason to feel less than electrified about our reputation.

You can recognise that negative images about us are coloured by hypocritical and racist outlooks. But unless you’re blind, you can also recognise that this observation does not change the influence and effect of those images.

Just one thing will change the power of such perceptions. That’s when the people here and on this continent harness our own power — both the electrical and the political … and the connections between; when we can properly synchronise our votes and our volts.

Meanwhile, next time the electricity is off, experience a positive African night-time image. That swathe of stars called the Milky Way by English-speaking Westerners has a different indigenous resonance. It’s said to be the effect of sunlight shining through the blackness. The pricks of light only penetrate because God’s cattle have worn holes in the sky as they daily trudge the same path to his heavenly kraal.

Despite Eskom and all the egregious politics, if the beauty of that image doesn’t make you feel proud to be an African, go get yourself a generator.




Related Posts

9 Responses to “Astronomy the answer to Eskom and our injured national pride”

[…] Astronomy the answer to Eskom and our injured national pride Thought Leader - Johannesburg,South Africa You can recognise that negative images about us are coloured by hypocritical and racist outlooks. But unless you’re blind, you can also recognise that this … See all stories on this topic […]

(Report abuse)

Astronomy Pictures - Images of moon on January 29th, 2008 at 6:30 pm

An external observer’s perspective: In my experience of discussions about South Africa with other ‘First World’ (hate that label, btw!) folk, it’s disappointment, not racism, that flavours the conversation. The disappointment comes from burdening SA with the collective hopes & expectations of outsiders (disappointed in their own lands) desperate to believe that the nation which so bravely unshackled itself from centuries of white oppression, with a display of extraordinary heart and the harnessed power of forgiveness, will confound its detractors.

And, it’s hard to blame foreign journalists for reporting SA through a negative prism in the current climate – it’s the convergence of all the scandal and bad news that makes for such an arresting and powerful (bad puns intended) story.

So, thanks for the beautiful imagery of the night sky over Africa. It’s the same sky I marvel at in the dark from my farmhouse porch on the outskirts of Canberra, where the absence of street lights is a blessing.

And this may make you feel better about your own infrastructure problems: I live 25kms from Australia’s seat of government but my (ancient) phone line goes down after each rainfall; my property has no mobile phone coverage and; our national water crisis means I have to truck drinking water in (via an unsealed road). But I’m not isolated enough to avoid the cultural cringe associated with a national holiday that celebrates the invasion of Aboriginal Australia and the international embarrassment visited by marauding sports fans chanting “Aussie, Aussie, Aussie - Oi, Oi, Oi”!

Here’s one Aussie cheering SA on: “Africa, Africa, Africa! Go, go, go! Here ends essay.

(Report abuse)

Julie Posetti on January 30th, 2008 at 1:15 am

Nice title but very little substance.

(Report abuse)

Sam on January 30th, 2008 at 2:16 pm

Nobody thought worse of them? The governor of California, Democrat Gray Davis, became only the second state governor in American history to be recalled. Voters, enraged over the electricity crisis, replaced him with Republican Arnold Schwarzenegger.

Pacific Gas and Electric went bust, and Southern California Edison needed a bailout. Companies that gamed the flawed regulations paid billions of dollars in settlements, and at least one, Enron, went bankrupt under a cloud of criminal charges.

I don’t know who you know that thought highly of the Californian state government, Governor Davis and Enron, but there can’t be very many of them.

Those of use who are highly upset are upset not only because of the likely cost to our economy and our capability for reducing poverty, building prosperty and creating jobs (which strikes me as a perfectly justifiable reason for outrage), but also because we’re proud South Africans. We’re, frankly speaking, ashamed of our leaders’ failures, and aren’t prepared to let them slide. We’re ashamed that, unlike Governor Davis, nobody is being held accountable for this disaster.

Patriotism implies proud loyalty to your country, not blind loyalty to leaders who fail in their responsibility to their citizens.

(Report abuse)

Ivo Vegter on January 30th, 2008 at 2:21 pm

Thank you Ivo Vegter, someone must not only take responsibility, but also suffer the consequences of their bad/misguided judgments.

(Report abuse)

Nqina Dlamini on January 30th, 2008 at 3:12 pm

[…] then you hear moonstruck positive-thinking delusions like those of journalism professor Guy Berger, and you despair for the future of this […]

(Report abuse)

Where's the outrage? « the spike on January 30th, 2008 at 8:31 pm

[…] then you hear moonstruck, positive-thinking delusions like those of journalism professor Guy Berger, and you despair for the future of this […]

(Report abuse)

Thought Leader » Ivo Vegter » Where's the outrage? on January 31st, 2008 at 10:15 am

Ivo misses my point. The drum I was beating was that no one assumed Californians as a class were inherently incompetent; not the issue of whether heads rolled. On the other hand, if we saw some decapitations here, maybe it would lift the wider fug and reduce the generalised sense of predictable Africa.

As to being moonstruck, I hope Ivo is not such an earnest capitalist agitator or so consumed by unfettered rage that he has lost any sense of humour or perspective. Try a bit of lunar solace, Ivo!

(Report abuse)

Guy Berger on February 3rd, 2008 at 10:08 am

I thought describing you as moonstruck was quite amusing, actually ;-)

But fair enough. I’ve called both this government and Eskom as incompetent, and disputed the wisdom of an economic policy that not only underlies this failure, but also increases the gravity of its impact by preventing alternative service providers to pick up the dropped ball.

I have, however, never described South Africans (or worse, some have charged, black South Africans) as a class as incompetent. On the contrary, and I have been quite explicit about this in my commentary, angry though it is.

I have every confidence in the resourcefulness, ingenuity and energy of individual South Africans. But that means considering the people on their own merits, and not simply by the proxy of a paternalistic government.

(Report abuse)

Ivo Vegter on February 3rd, 2008 at 10:37 am

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

We have put a word limit of 250 words on all your comments


words left

profile
Guy Berger is a media academic/activist. He writes a fortnightly column at www.mg.co.za/converse and is active in the South African National Editors' Forum. He also blogs about teaching journalism and new media. Find his research online and micro-blogging from conferences at http://www.twitter.com/guyberger
Tell a Friend Technorati RSS
more posts
South Africa's journalism schools have joined the movement to keep the country's media and information environment free. More than a dozen schools...
Thirty years ago this month, six security police arrested a journalism lecturer at Rhodes University. They held him incommunicado and interrogated him...
Most media responses to the ANC's recently released discussion document have come out fighting. The particular target is the proposed media appeal...
It was topsy-turvy at two conferences in Johannesburg last week. What you'd expect was not what happened: Delegates at the event convened by the C...
Strangely, at a time when South Africans are beginning to benefit from better and cheaper broadband connectivity, our communications regulator is toyi...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 38643
Total comments 475
Guy's tags
advertisement
    Mail & Guardian Online Headlines
  • National
  • Business
  • Africa
  • World
  • Sport
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator