Fiona Snyckers
Fiona Snyckers

Local erotic fiction goes global

In the same week that South Africa’s first mainstream erotic novel for women hit shelves, a major publishing deal was announced that is poised to take local erotica worldwide.

There are those who chose to link these two events with the horrific rape and murder of Anene Booysen — the implication being that women’s erotic expression is somehow connected to the culture of sexual violence in this country.

It is more constructive to see women’s increased comfort with their own sexuality as a significant poke in the eye to patriarchy, and something to be celebrated rather than shamed back into hiding. Homegrown erotic fiction is an example of South African literature finally coming into its own.

Literary agent Oliver Munson of AM Heath & Co in London announced the sale of a “choose your own adventure” erotica series written by South African writers Sarah Lotz, Helen Moffett and Paige Nick under the pseudonym Helena S Paige.

Rights to the series have been sold in the UK, the US, and South Africa. Translation rights have been sold in 10 countries so far. There is no doubt that this series is regarded as major news in the world of international publishing.

I asked Helen Moffett why the medium of fiction has proved so successful in women’s erotica.

“I’m no expert,” she replied, “but I suspect it’s the old adage of the most powerful sexual organ being the one between the ears. My close men-friends tell me that the male brain is sexually stimulated via the eyes — that looking, the visual aspect of sex, is what they find erotic. Women take in erotica via the eyes differently — we seem to prefer print as a medium that tickles our fancy. And other bits. Possibly because this means we can shape or project the fantasy to suit ourselves, a basic principle underlying The Girl Walks Into series”.

Fifty Shades of Grey initially grew in popularity through word of mouth alone, which Paige Nick attributes to erotica becoming a more accepted form of enjoyment for women: “Reading erotica is a deeply private and intimate experience for a woman. However what I think the Fifty Shades series did was give a lot of women permission to enjoy erotica. Before this, erotica had always been a brown bag genre, but now the feeling is if everybody else is doing it, then it must be okay. So the spreading and sharing of the news of it is social and communal, as it would be for a good recipe, or a great movie that’s out on the circuit.”

What clearly had publishers reaching for their wallets in this case was the ”choose your own adventure” aspect of the series. Moffett didn’t want to give too much of the premise away, but commented: “We were sick of erotica and romance in which women are passive, and everything is done to them, often by an older, wiser man who ‘coaches’ them. Why don’t we let women choose? Why can’t they walk into a room and pick whoever and whatever they fancy, with the freedom to change their minds halfway through? So they can choose male, female, older, younger, experienced, innocent — or to go home to hot chocolate and a good book. Whatever they want, it’s their decision, they have the power.”

Jassy Mackenzie is the author of Folly — arguably South Africa’s first mainstream erotic novel. Her novel is notable as much for its intelligent use of humour as for its sex scenes. I asked her whether it was a risk to mix humour with sex in a genre that traditionally takes itself very seriously indeed.

“The humour in Folly was essential,” said Mackenzie, “because in this book the heroine is in charge, rather than being the more typically portrayed submissive. I hoped that by making the domination scenes funny it would engage the readers without the story becoming too ‘heavy’. The humour also helps to differentiate Emma’s other clients from her love interest, Simon. The scenes with him swiftly become more serious and more erotic, with the other sessions providing some light relief”.

One thing that Folly and Fifty Shades have in common is the over-arching love story. I asked Mackenzie whether it was a cliché to assume that woman prefer a helping of romance with their sex.

“I think women enjoy the process of seduction,” Mackenzie speculated. “Whether they’re seducing their love interest or being seduced by them. It’s a more complex and multifaceted journey than the plot of — shall we say — plumber rings doorbell to be met by housewife with large breasts. For us, love plays an important role because it involves our emotions in the process.”

Sex scenes are notoriously very difficult to get right. Paige Nick admitted that this is one of the more challenging aspects of writing erotic fiction: “Look, it’s not hard like removing a brain tumour is hard, but writing sex scenes is definitely tricky, for a couple of reasons. The first is that no author wants to write bad sex. You don’t want to turn your reader off, make them cringe, throw a speed bump into the story, or even worse, bore them. Particularly when there are multiple sex scenes in one book, as is the case with the A Girl series. Each one needs to be unique and original, or else you’ve lost your reader and done your job badly.”

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

  • Should local writers always set their books in South Africa?
  • Behind the shock and awe, the violence is ‘normal’
  • South Africa and that Time cover
  • Anene, Reeva media frenzy reveals a nation’s shallowness
  • 10 Responses to “Local erotic fiction goes global”

    1. Jennifer #

      Sigh really and now we are analysing it, am thrilled for those who will make money out of writing, but let’s not pretend this is anything other than what it is, catching a trend wave and riding it, and good for them, but mentioning a 17-year-old rape victim (sadly we can’t use the oh so politically correct term survivor here) boggles my mind. I will probably read both books and enjoy them, so will every lift-club mom and a few men blah blah blah. But spare us the lofty analysis really.

      February 13, 2013 at 12:24 pm
    2. SL #

      I find it very hard to support this sort of venture in a climate of constant abuse of South African women.
      It is not feminist (or progressive if you prefer) simply because you say you are giving women the choice. It seems obvious to me that here is simply another way to get middle class women to buy books, without actually engaging patriachy in this, or any other, society.
      The challenge would be to write erotic novels which actually challenge the roots of patriachy, and sexism. But good luck finding a publisher to publish it (given recent history, I think most publishers are looking for a quick sell to women who believe they are modern, but who go home and accept all the usual roles in a deeply patriachal society, as happened with Fifty Shades of Grey).
      So, be honest then, the writers are making some money, hell maybe they even deserve it. BUT they are NOT doing anything for South African or any other women.

      February 13, 2013 at 3:21 pm
    3. Jozi #

      Anybody say South Africa / dichotomy?
      Oh to be white, middle aged and middle class in South Africa post apartheid. Blissful ignorance for writers and book buyers.
      Ps. Fiona take Anene’s name out of your article.

      February 13, 2013 at 3:50 pm
    4. Paul S #

      Maybe there are those who choose to link the terrible rape with the launch, but they will be a tiny minority. Don’t amplify this and give the grandstanders something to grab hold of. You are writing about the power of the word yet ironically you are missing the gravity of the connection you are creating.

      February 13, 2013 at 5:37 pm
    5. Momma Cyndi #

      Why not? Made a fortune for Mills and Boon and for Barbra Cartland. Good luck, girls. Hope it is your ticket to ride. Not my type of reading choice but, then again, neither was the penny horribles of those days.

      How DID Anene’s name get mixed into this ????

      February 13, 2013 at 7:02 pm
    6. Of course the proposed series is intended to surf the current commercial wave but so what. Will it help to counter the prevailing societal view of hetero-sexual women only as bit players in sexual activities dictated by men? I hope so. It will be to the benefit of us all. I say hetero-sexual women because, I guess, gay women are naturally free of that particular societal millstone.

      February 14, 2013 at 6:12 pm
    7. JN #

      The irritation arises not only as a result of the opportunistic invoking of Anene Booysen’s name in what is really a PR fluff piece. There are other problematic aspects to it, amongst them the uncritical assumptions that women’s consumption of ‘naughty’ books equates to their empowerment, and that women getting their rocks off writing and reading about sex has even the vaguest impact on real world gender stuff, or patriarchy, if you like. Women generated erotica/porn may be fun, yet another late capitalist cultural quirk, like Buzzfeed, but it would go down a lot better without the utopianist marketing angles.
      Plus, it feels kind of late in the day, and almost quaint, to be celebrating women’s “increased comfort with their own sexuality”. This may be laggard South Africa, but the year is 2013, and many of us have long ago reached a point of being comfortable with our sexuality, whatever that means. Probably not much in the world of Anene Booysen in any event.

      February 14, 2013 at 7:14 pm
    8. Jane #

      Anene Booysen was a girl who walked into a bar. … perhaps that is how her name got mixed up in this

      February 14, 2013 at 9:45 pm
    9. Sandra #

      Shades of Grey was a revolting book – I didn’t finish it.

      February 15, 2013 at 7:45 am

    Trackbacks/Pingbacks

    1. Fiona Snyckers Talks to Jassy Mackenzie, Helen Moffett and Paige Nick About Writing Erotica | Books LIVE - February 14, 2013

      [...] Complete article: Mail & Guardian [...]

    Leave a Reply

     characters available