« Blog Home
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...

I am as sentimental as the next person. Really, I am. And I did my Shakespeare at school, and I know the story about the tragic hero — a great man, with a fatal flaw. I love those Elizabethan tragedies, real and imagined: poor Mary, Queen of Scots, going bravely to her death in a red kirtle, to signify that she was a martyr. (I think a kirtle is a sort of petticoat — I should look that up.)

In fact, any lonely queen going to her death can choke me up: poor Marie Antoinette, on the bumpy tumbrel, heading towards the guillotine. And don’t get me going on the tsar and his family in the cellar in Yekaterinburg.

I am not sure why I found myself pondering these things while listening to President Thabo Mbeki’s resignation speech. His penchant for Shakespeare, of course. The phrase he used about the loneliness of leadership. Of course he is not going to his death, except in a metaphorical political sense. Nevertheless, I was feeling pretty sorry for the bloke.

Unfortunately, he had to go and spoil it by talking about his achievements, and he had to mention women. Well, yes, he did appoint a bunch of women. Fired them pretty damn quick when they got uppity — Pregs Govender, Thandi Modise. Well, Pregs resigned, and Modise got shunted out to the provinces, but you know what I mean. And is it too cynical to say that many of the women he appointed then owed him, and had no major political base of their own?

And rape. Well, we all know about his intense unease with the way black male sexuality is constructed in Africa, and his (probably accurate) sense that the discourse around rape can play into some nasty little racist sentiments. But that ended up with him questioning the incidence of rape, which led to his ministers doing so. Sigh.

And customary law. His inability to grab it, and infuse equality into it, has meant the gradual erosion of customary law. It may have been inevitable, and the survival of customary law may itself have been a legacy of apartheid. And I concede that it may have been an impossible task. But his government did not deal proactively with the customary laws of succession, and dealt with marriage such that customary marriages before 2000 remain completely brutally unfair, with the wife not sharing in the estate, irrespective of her contribution. This the Constitutional Court is being asked to remedy, as it did the law of succession — but why the courts, and not Parliament?

And HIV. Let’s not even go there.

So, I stopped feeling too bad. I can’t resist a bit of Shakespeare, though:

Now cracks a noble heart. Good night, sweet prince,
And flights of angels sing thee to thy rest.




Related Posts

9 Responses to “Mbeki as tragic hero — not”

I am dying, Egypt. Dying.

(Report abuse)

Jon on September 22nd, 2008 at 11:27 am

[…] I see that Alison Tilley over at Thoughtleader has had similar (but also quite different) ideas on this subject. And Zapiro, […]

(Report abuse)

Mbeki as Shakesperian tragic hero « Couch trip on September 22nd, 2008 at 1:55 pm

Allison, I just don’t get the thrust of you message here. Did you expect President Mbeki to do a mea culpa a thousand different times for the duration of his speech? Just what’s wrong in listing one’s achievements, if these are the things you are elected to do? As for customary law, isn’t that the function of the courts and the legislature and not the executive? - and where in the speech did he say anything about rape? I get the feeling you needed to say something negative and went about scratching very hard within your rather limited head space.

(Report abuse)

KC on September 22nd, 2008 at 2:30 pm

Trite, shallow and schmaltzy.

(Report abuse)

Dante on September 22nd, 2008 at 2:32 pm

The tragedy is not Mbeki’s. The tragedy is South Africa’s.

And people like you, Alison, did your little best to make it happen by smearing the Mbeki government and refusing to criticise the corporate-backed gang who were being brought in.

But of course you would never dream of accepting personal responsibility for anything.

(Report abuse)

MFB on September 22nd, 2008 at 2:57 pm

There are those (few I must mention) who loathe every good thing that comes out of Africa. Ofcourse the same hypocritically lament every ill coming out of Africa. They assume that every good thing in this continent should come from their kind.

These dinosaurs irritate some, but to others they are necessary scums that will highlight to our children and the coming generations the origins of racism, slavery and other evils that have been endured by Africans

Mbeki has done an excellent job as a president with all his mistakes

Former President Mandela once alluded to the fact that there has never been a president or prime minister in SA who has achieved as much as President Thabo Mbeki has achieved.

(Report abuse)

Babas on September 22nd, 2008 at 3:19 pm

“The evil that men do lives after them. The good is often interred with their bones”

(Report abuse)

Lyndall Beddy on September 22nd, 2008 at 7:48 pm

Hey, what’s with the brutal dissing of Allison? She had a few thoughts as she watched Thabo resign, as did I, and I’m sure neither of us expected him to mea culpa for one seccy! Comrade Thabo was deep in the pockets of the corporates, and so will his successor be, is already - would that be ameliorated by Allison and her ilk zipping their lips and not speaking ill of those in power?
Yeah, he did a great job. At what, exactly? I was at a funeral a while back - the mother of a nine-year-old boy who died because she got antiretrovirals - too late to save her life. She took her place among the rows and rows of raw, red graves, all bearing pathetic little sticks with names and ages on them: Khomotso, aged 29; Slindile, aged 34…
Then a friend took a dying woman to Helen Joseph. She was dying beause she was given antiretrovirals, they gave her some side-effects, she went back to the clinic where a NURSING SISTER told her not to take them, “They are poison”. This evil sits directly at Thabo’s door. Don’t tell me through this medium about how wonderful he was at diplomacy or something nice and abstract like that; come with me to the graves, those nice, new graves, and in front of the orphans of young mothers and fathers, tell me what a great man he was…

(Report abuse)

Mandi K on September 23rd, 2008 at 3:02 pm

Mandi - I Agree with you wholeheartedly, however the blame does not only lie with Thabo. The Whole African National Clown’s policy on AIDS was at fault. And there were many other Clowns that stood out in the AID’s controversy, Including Zuma, who’s AID’s dissidence, amongst other failures has earned him a promotion to ANC President. I feel it is “out of the frying Pan, and into the fire” for South Africa. Thabo did Fail, the African National Clowns as a whole Has failed even more, and we, the people will bear the brunt of the failures.

(Report abuse)

cyberdog on September 24th, 2008 at 6:58 pm

Leave a Reply

All comments must be approved by our editors, click here to read the editorial guidelines for comments. Please allow some time for our editors to approve your comment after posting.

Send me the Thought Leader daily newsletter

We have put a word limit of 250 words on all your comments


words left

profile
Alison Tilley is an attorney working at the Open Democracy Advice Centre as the CEO. She specialises in right to know law. She is a founding trustee of the Women's Legal Centre, and has a keen interest in gender issues.
Tell a Friend Technorati RSS
more posts
I met a really interesting Syrian football fan in Nature's Valley in the Western Cape during the World Cup. His way of avoiding the apparently terrify...
I met Noel Robb at a momentous time, for the country and myself. I had just decided to give up practice as a lawyer, and become what was known as the ...
Rape. It is a hard thing to think about, and not usually the subject of cartoons. Did the Zapiro cartoon cross the line? And what is that line, anyway...
I am often baffled by what makes the news and what doesn’t. I mean let’s just assume for argument’s sake, we have a showdown between the longsta...
‘Games over, Free Tibet’ is one of the really good slogans coming out of the Free Tibet campaign. The campaign has got a lot of press recently. Mo...
latest activity
Blog Statistics
Total reads 1286
Total comments 191
Alison's tags
advertisement
    Mail & Guardian Online Headlines
  • National
  • Business
  • Africa
  • World
  • Sport
All material copyright of the author, or the Mail & Guardian, unless otherwise specified
Author Login
Afrigator